Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
Posted by Joe Wright on 11/19/2014
The pizza was old. The toppings were skimpy. And lastly, it took over an hour to arrive. I was very disappointed. Never again will uncle Mario's get my business. This was the worst pizza I've ever had!
Posted by hellskitchen on 01/30/2014
The delivery order was wrong. The marinara sauce was watery. In general, the meal was bland, there was no visual evidence or taste of herbs or garlic.
Posted by CuisineCrazy on 11/06/2013
What looks like a pizza place/tourist trap in the theatre district is actually far better. Not "gourmet", but really very good food. Had linguine with clam sauce, al dente as requested with at least a dozen manila clams in the shell, opened, on top of the pasta. A vey memorable waitress/hostess, Carmella, direct from Italy! The space and décor is very low-end, but the food, for what it is, is very high quality. I'll be back.
Posted by grancy on 10/26/2013
After seeing a matinee nearby, I took my granddaughters for pizza. The pizza was amazing, thin crispy crust and plenty of cheese. The only disappointment we had was the restaurant staff was moving tables and chairs around. The furniture moving and noise it created was quite uncomfortable.
Posted by optngal on 08/23/2013
visited this place for the first time on Wed after a matinee. my out of town guests wanted 'white' pizza. we ordered the three cheese pizza, ceasar salad and mozzarella sticks. the pizza crust was thin and crisp and not overbaked. the salad, though over dressed, was good. we were disappointed with the mozzarella sticks as they were mostly fried breading. our waitress was friendly making for an all around good experience.
Posted by Etnino on 01/24/2013
Me and my wife where in NY for 5 days (23-28 Semtember 2012). We where looking to eat something different from hotdog and similar... Our hotel where in 48th street and so at the end of our stay we found this restaurant. We where luky because waiter coming from Sicily Catania as me.
Posted by Frank & Adele from Arizona on 06/09/2012
We are native New Yorkers now living in Arizona. We were in NYC for 2 weeks and found Uncle Mario's on Menupages. It was so good the first time that we came back again with our other family members, also from Arizona. We ordered pies, lasagna, pasta, shrimp parmagiana. Everything was excellent. Our waitress was a throwback to the glory days of the NY Italian restaurant. She makes you feel like you're part of the family. When we come back again, we will make this our first night;s dining spot. We will also be passing the word to family and friends that they stop by as well. The only 2 drawbacks are that if you get there at the wrong time, you will have to wait. But it is worth it. The 2nd drawback is that they don't have a place in food starved Scottsdale, AZ.