Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Anonymous on 04/25/2013
I hate to leave a negative review but I have to be honest. Delivery was 30 minutes later than the nearly 1-hour originally anticipated delivery time. In addition, I have to say it was the worst tasting pizza I have had in 13 years living in New York City. The pizza sauce had absolutely NO flavor - worse than the most bland spaghetti sauce, no Italian or other seasoning, or 'real' tomatoes - just a thin, tasteless coating on the crust. It even SMELLED bad. And the garlic knots were raw. Very disappointed - will never order from here again!
Posted by Anonymous on 06/29/2011
I love their chicken cutlet parm over ziti and for dessert Baklava. Great affordable quality place. Love it
Posted by Inwood Responder on 02/03/2011
Being a long time Inwoodite, I have had food from every pizza place in the area & can tell you from experience, Tony's is the best. Tony's has, hands down, the best you can find in the neighborhood. so what if you have to wait a little extra time because you want it super fresh & just made. that happens anywhere you order from.
Posted by John Cosmos on 12/13/2010
I Read the last Review and I have to disagree. Tony's is pretty fast considering everything is made fresh. If you want a pie 15 minutes after you order it then order frozen from Dominoes. If you want fresh you gotta wait a little longer guys. The Gyros, Greek salads and all there Greek Dishes are great. The Italian dishes are very good. The italian sandwiches and the pastas with Meatballs, Sausage, Chicken, and veal are GREAT! I tried them all. So I give them a A and I am glad there are serving our neighboorhood.
Posted by Anonymous on 05/15/2010
DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY FROM THESE PEOPLE! I ordered a small pie at 9:00pm and it finally arrived at !0:25pm ! Although they gave me two extra cans of soda, the pizza looked like the delivery guy dropped the box! Their pizza is good but you are better off picking it up yourself.
Posted by Mayor of Inwood on 02/12/2010
Everyone knows Tony's. He been in the neighboorhood for 45 Years. He took over this spot 5 yeears ago. He just started the ONE DOLLAR slice of pizza and the 2 for 3 dollars on the weekends. To help out the young ones to afford a slice after school he said. Tony's pizza has a great menu and lots of diferent Greek and Italian foods. It's small and cozy and always fresh ingredients. Its a great pizzeria. Probably one of the best. You'll See for yourself. Go check it out. There on face book too at Tony's Pizza and Gyro.
Posted by Another Tony on 05/02/2008
I really like this place, and it's not because I share the same name as the establishment. I've always found the staff not too pushy, compared to the pizza joints downtown that are too cool for school. What you see is what you get at Tony's It's your typical straight forward New York pizza joint. They have a few fancy pizzas, nothing too out of the norm, and they have a pretty standard spread of New York/Italian basics. In addition, their patties make for good eats wile you're running to the A-Train. Sandwiches are equally as good (nice and crispy, if that's the way you like them). All and all, this place is one of my more favorite standard pizza joints In(the)Wood. Great for one of those cold windy nights when you don't feel like going out to pick up some food.