
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by annamae on 02/02/2012
couldn't get into Carmine's
So happy we discovered "Tony"s"....two years ago...the girls in my salon couldn't make up our minds...on what to do for our Christmas celebration....we love a good party...good dancing music...but we decided we needed a change...so off to manhattan for a broadway show and a good dinner....low and behold the famous Carmine's just couldn't accommodate us...I believe that year we were 14 girls...after some discussion and a suggestion from a client we decided to go to"Tony's"...a little skeptical..(most of us are italian and fabulous cooks) we off to our night out....my daughter and i spent the day in manhattan and the the rest followed...we were greeted by a lovely hostess...she checked our reservation...asked if we would like to wait for the rest of the party,,,Have a drink"....which we did...the gals trickled in and within ten minutes..we were seated......the waitress introduced her self announced the specials and we were on our way....fast and efficient...the service was impeccable....we asked about certain dishes and was able to answer every question.......the food was serviced in a timely fashion...water glasses filled and drinks renewed....the food was superior....we had not one complaint.....we are still laughing about the amount of food ordered......and EATEN.......long story short.....there was no question where we were eating this year for our night on the town..... forget the five rating Tony DiNapoli gets a ten....from the gals at Vanity Salon, Merrick NY!
Posted by EricIz on 01/07/2012
Great choice!
We made a resv. the same morning and when we arrived a great romantic table was waiting for us. We chose the Friday night special which consisted of black seafood pasta loaded with calamari,shrimp,clams and mussels. Great salad as well with a few glasses of chianti made this a great choice. We'll be back!
Posted by Diane L on 01/06/2012
all time favorite
Been coming to this restaurant for many years now and refuse to eat anywhere else when I'm in the city Sent many people here and they all love it
Posted by Taylor on 12/11/2011
Best. Ever. Period.
My mom and I visited in August based on a recommendation from a New Yorker and we fell in love. We made a reservation an hour before we came and when we arrived, the restaurant was packed yet we still got a table within 15 minutes. We ordered a half-order of calamari which was still a lot. We ordered stuffed ravioli which was delectable. The meal was amazing and great for a New York meal. It wasn't very expensive. I fell in love and I will return every time I make a trip to NY. Btw, we are from Atlanta.
Posted by anonymous on 11/18/2011
good food, poor service
Food was ok, but our waiter was very unfriendly. Wasn't even finished drinking my glass or he ripped it out of my hands. 1 minute later the bill was there (unasked). Clearly he worked us out , we had to go, make room for other people. A disgrace !
Posted by Anonymous on 11/05/2011
Awesome choice!
Great choice on our second day in NY. Food was great, service was tops, and the decor was pleasing. Highly recommended!
Posted by Sarit on 03/03/2011
great!
highly recommended! we gave very warm recommendations to all our freinds in Israel. great food! very much valued for money and a very good service. well done!