Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Tillman's Bar & Lounge (CLOSED)

  • American
  • 165 W 26th St, NEW YORK 10001 40.745914 -73.993572
  • (Btwn 6th & 7th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 627-8320
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 16 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 3_5 Value 2_5
Service 2_5 Atmosphere 3_5

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 627-8320
Visa, MC, AmEx
Mon-Tue: 5pm-2am Wed-Sat: 5pm-4am
Accepts Credit Cards, Late Night, Live Music, Private Parties, Romantic

User Reviews

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by Anonymous on 2010-06-01

    Never Again

    The overpriced grilled cheese was good, but the service was terrible and then they had the nerve to add a mandatory 20% gratuity on top of our bill (for a party of 3!). When we asked about it, we were given a number of different excuses, including: (1) It

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by ayo2424 on 2009-11-09

    Don't Waste Your Time.

    Why people come back to this place is beyond me. Pushy doormen, negligent waitress, downright rude manager. Food was decent, the atmosphere wonderful, but (hyperbole aside) the service was the worst i've ever experienced.

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by Ayoo48 on 2009-03-25

    unfriendly staff

    Staff was extremely unfriendly, as though it was a privilege to eat "gourmet grilled cheese". There is really nothing on the menu. They serve mac and cheese in a cup, soup in a glass. Over the years I've been to countless pretentious wanna be 5 star soul

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by Esha W. on 2009-02-20

    Tillmans Rocks!

    My date and I stumbled upon Tillmans a few days ago. This place is awesome, the food, the decor, the music, and even the drinks. But most important, the strawberry short cake is to die for. I recommend this place, whether a date or just hanging with the f

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by fridaholic on 2009-02-13

    high strung staff, arbitrary rules, good but overpriced comfort food

    i've never heard of a restaurant where you have to check your coat. i never check my coat, in part, because i'm far more likely to loose that ticket that loose my jacket. the menu is limited, the staff (particularly the male manager) is high-strung, borde

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by I felt very unwelcome on 2009-01-05

    A very unwelcoming experience

    Although we had a great grilled cheese sandwich and chips, the steak sandwich was only ok. The staff could not have been worse. We were apparently evaluated as not-cool-enough for the place and even though it was 6:00 on a Saturday night we were relegated

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by Poorly Managed on 2008-11-11

    So Great Yet So Wrong at The Same Time

    I was approached by the Maitre'D who obnoxiously and rudely offered we move to another table because champagne was not considered a bottle. Seriously? This was offered after appetizers were ordered and the waitress, who was great by the way, took our dri

  • Tillman's Bar & Lounge

    Posted by MISS 360 on 2008-09-24

    DON'T DO IT!

    They force you to buy a bottle of liquor without telling you @ the time you make your reservation or before seating you. If you do not purchase a bottle, duty manager will force you to leave your table, even after you've spent money on dinner & drinks. Th

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.