Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Thistle Hill Tavern

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (Traditional), American (New), Local/Organic
  • 441 7th Ave, Brooklyn NY11215 40.663177 -73.984517
  • (At 15th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (347) 599-1262
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 16 reviews)

Food 3.7 Value 3.5
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 3.7

Other Restaurant Info

(347) 599-1262
(347) 599-2099
Place Order:
Order From Thistle Hill Tavern for delivery & takeout
Visa, MC Bar Hours Daily: -12am
Dinner Sun-Wed: 5pm-11pm Brunch Sat-Sun: 11am-4pm
Brunch, Dinner
Accepts Credit Cards, Bar Scene, Delivery, Good for Groups, Late Night, Online Ordering, Outdoor Seating, Take Out, Trendy, Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery Area:
4th Ave- Prospect Park W, 9th St - Prospect Expy, Prospect Park SW, Fort Hamilton Pkwy

User Reviews

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by NickD on 05/24/2013

    I have to correct this...

    Previous reviewer said they would never go back because they couldn't take the rest of their mussels home. This is a rule from the NYC health department. Cooked shellfish can't be delivered or wrapped up to go. If other restaurants allowed it, they were breaking health code.

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by very disappointed on 07/10/2012


    I couldn't finish half my mussels....asked to take the rest with me. since I don't have a big appetite..I was told that I couldn't take them with me...I had to pay for them , but couldn't take the rest...I have never had this problem in any restaurant. I will never go back again.

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by obitsfan on 05/14/2012

    Wonderful Brunch

    My son works across the street at Slope Cellars and is a regular at Thistle Hill Tavern. He brought me there for brunch on Mother's Day. I had the "Breakfast" which was the ricotta pancake, egg and bacon. it was an unexpected delight. The food was fresh and very tasty. I am definity looking forward to eating there again, possibly for dinner.

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by Anonymous on 07/17/2011

    Heavy food with way too much butter.

    I have given Thistle Hill about five chances. Everything they serve seems heavy or overly buttered. I cannot explain what it is, but it is too much. The last time I went there, the price tag for two small children and myself ( a couple of appetizers and two main courses) with sodas, came to around $90.00 with tip. I felt like crying. Never, never will I go there again. On the upside, the service is out of this world as is the decor. Go there and judge for yourself, but do not finish a full portion as there must be at least a stick of butter used for each one.

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by Anonymous on 06/26/2011

    Several highs, a couple lows

    I went to THT with high expectations and was not disappointed. The ambiance is lovely. A brooklyn restaurant done right. We had to wait a lot longer than we were originally told, but the host apologized and we luckily had a seat at the bar so it was fine. To start with the lows, the falafel and mussels were just ok. Not bad at all, just nothing special. The octopus and the donuts however were lovely. The octopus portion could have been a little bigger, but I certainly did not leave hungry. The highlight of the meal, and the reason I will most certainly go back, was the fried fennel. It was to die for! We seriously considered getting a second order for dessert! All in all, a very good restaurant.

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by bklyn837 on 06/24/2011

    Happy Both Times

    Been twice within the last few weeks and found the food to be very good on both occasions. First time was a party of 4 adults and a 20 month old on a very busy warm Friday night in June. Although it was extremely busy, the owner was very accomodating and helpful in getting us seated and providing enough bread to keep the tot busy. All four of us walked away from the restaurant saying that it was one of the best dinners we'd had in a long time. Last night 2 of us went for dinner and really enjoyed. Fav appetizers so far include fried fennel, braised endive and figs and burrata. Hamburger was well liked by many at the table - I'm not a big burger fan so hard for me to say, but the octopus entree was excellent. Only slight disappointment was mac n cheese. Thistle Hill is a very welcome addition to Park Slope dining scene.

  • Thistle Hill Tavern

    Posted by Park Slope Food Veteran on 03/14/2011

    Don't get the pork chop

    The most expensive thing on the menu and possibly the worst. Pork chop was paper thin and dry. Bad presentation with the tough beet leaves just thrown on top. BBQ beans were the best part but just OK. Where do they get off charging $25? What a joke. I don't care much for portion sizes but for that price and the underwhelming quality I would've expected to be full at least. No such luck. They could at least provide bread!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.