Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

The Smith

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (Traditional), Cocktails
  • 55 3rd Ave, New York NY10003 40.731123 -73.988736
  • (Btwn 10th & 11th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 420-9800
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 88 reviews)

Food 4.0 Value 3.7
Service 4.1 Atmosphere 4.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 420-9800
Place Order:
Order From The Smith for delivery & takeout
Visa, MC, AmEx
Mon-Wed: 8am-12am Thu-Fri: 8am-1am Sat: 9:30am-1am Sun: 9:30am-12am
Breakfast, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Bar Scene, Brunch, Catering, Delivery, Good for Groups, Late Night, Online Ordering, Online Reservations, Raw Bar, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:
Delivery Area:
Houston to 23rd St; Ave B to Broadway

User Reviews

  • The Smith

    Posted by cat on 03/28/2008

    Nice Dinner

    The place has a cool decor. We were lucky to get a booth and it was really comfortable for four people. Waiter was very nice and patient. I had two of their muddler drinks - The Ginger Smash which was really refresing and sweet. It had bits of pineapple and ginger in it. A the Loco Cucumber and it was refreshing too like a cucumber. We had the Mac and Cheese as an App and it was delicious. Very creamy inside, but with a crunchy top. I would go back for that in a minute.. Then I had the Tuna Tartare,, They didn't try to reinvent the wheel with this one, but it was tasty and had a vinegar taste to it. I had the Lamb Schnitzel.. which actually tasted like a fried piece of Veal Cutlet. It was okay, but the mashed potatoes underneath were yummy. Very buttery and creamy, but they left some chunks of potatoe, which I like. I tried my friend's Short Rib and it was delicious. I wished I had ordered that. The mussels looked good too. They looked fresh and no fishy smell. Can't really ask for more that that with mussels.. My friend who is on a no-carb diet, had to dip the bread. Oh and the french bread on the table is delicious too. And the butter is room temperature, so you can spread it. Nice touch. We all dessert, but I was so stuffed, I should't have order the peanut butter ice cream. That was tooooo much. But cute spot, nice waiters and nice mixed crowd of people.

  • The Smith

    Posted by ASL on 03/25/2008

    Excellent Less Expensive Dinner Spot

    I was pleasantly surprised with The Smith. We had the mussel appetizer, halibut special, short ribs, and bread pudding sundae. We found everything to be delicious. The prices were reasonable. I really liked the house wine options and a full carafe was very reasonable for 4 people. The service was quirky, but good. The atmosphere could use a little work and the restaurant gets fairly loud. NYC needs more places like this…delicious food and drink for fairly decent prices. Maybe we got lucky, but our experience was very good and we hope to return soon.

  • The Smith

    Posted by Katie on 03/19/2008

    Great food, great service!

    I just went here the other day with my mom for dinner. Our waitor was very nice and helpful, and I loved the free sparkling water on every table. I had the Tomato Soup (with melted cheddar on top a la French onion soup) and then the Wild Mushroom Ravioli - both delicious. Best part about my experience - my entree came out lukewarm, so when I asked for it to be heated a bit, a few minutes later my waiter brought over the baked Mac+Cheese appetizer from the chef to hold me over while he made me a new order of the ravioli! By the time my entree came, I was full from the Mac+Cheese and had plenty of leftovers for the next day!

  • The Smith

    Posted by Amy on 03/16/2008


    The only thing that will stand out about my trip to The Smith is how poor the service was. I made a reservation days in advance which was confirmed via e-mail and on the phone. When my party of seven arrived on time for our 9:30 (Saturday) reservation, we were first asked to wait, and then after waiting 20 minutes we checked back with the hostess, who had accidentally checked us in under the wrong name. After another 15 minutes of standing in the crowded bar, we were seated and then rushed with both drink and dinner orders. The food was mediocre, but quite overpriced for all the hype. I'm never coming back.

  • The Smith

    Posted by bucks county, pa on 03/16/2008

    great place

    I've been to the the Smith a couple of times visiting my daughter who happens to be one of the hostesses. We came on my husbands birthday. Service was wonderful . First we had the mac & cheese WOW! One hundred times better than my home-made. The calamari was so tender not one chewy piece. It was just alittle to salty. I had the deluxe burger. The best every. My husband had the flat iron steak which he said was very tasty. The dipping sauce was way to salty. The dessert which we shared was bread pudding with ice cream and candied nuts. Just right to end the perfect day.

  • The Smith

    Posted by lizz on 02/24/2008

    great new spot - free sparkling water!

    the food and service here are fantastic. welcome addition to the neighborhood. my favorite - the unlimited free sparkling water and deeeelicious ice cream sundaes.

  • The Smith

    Posted by Gabriel on 02/20/2008

    get your act together unpleasant meal

    The place looks swanky, the bar is nice, and the servers are friendly, but the food is not good. The salad tasted like something from my local bodega, and the chicken sausage dish was overpriced and without taste. Don't even think about touching the spaghetti with meatballs... you may as well walk around the corner, pick up some Rao's, and make it on your own. I wanted to like this place so bad... but unfortunately, I hated it.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.