Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

The Mermaid Inn

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Seafood
  • 568 Amsterdam Ave, New York NY10024 40.788813 -73.974594
  • (Btwn 87th & 88th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 799-7400
  • 0


New England Clam Chowder bacon & fingerling potatoes   9.00
Jonah Crab Cake fennel, navel orange, frisée & dijon aioli   16.00
Lobster Knuckles Escargot grilled country bread, parsley & garlic butter   14.00
Portugese Octopus charred eggplant, fingerling potato, arugula &sopressata vainaigrette   14.00
Mermaid Wedge Salad cherry tomatoes, red onion, maytag blue cheese, apple-smoked bacon & buttermilk dressing   11.00
Seared Calamari cremini, shiitake, frisee & feta   13.00
Grilled Romaine Salad white anchovies, capers, shaved parmesan & lemon dressing   12.00
Mermaid Mini Clam Bake clams, mussels, shrimp & lobster   15.00


Roasted Local Skate broccoli rabe, roasted sweet potato & caper lemon brown butter   24.00
Blackened "Southern Style" Catfish hush puppies, collard greens & crayfish butter   23.00
Mustard Crusted Rainbow Trout ratatouille, pine nuts & petit basil   25.00
Spaghetti With Salad On Top seafood fra diavolo, garlic bread   25.00
Mermaid Fish Tacos beer batter, red cabbage, pickled jalapeños & pico de gallo   21.00
Lobster Sandwich grilled brioche bun & old bay fries. limited availability   28.00
Grilled Whole Market Fish extra virgin olive oil, sea salt & lemon   
Bone-In Pork Chop mustard maple glaze, kale & smoked bacon   25.00

Raw Bar

Chilled 1/2 Lobster    16.00
Oysters selection of east & west coast   
Littleneck Clams   (1/2 doz) 10.00
Classic Shrimp Cocktail    13.00
Yellow Fin Tuna Crudo jalapeno, avocado, lime & sea salt   12.00
Baby Grand Platter 6 oysters, 6 clams, tuna crudo   29.00
Grand Platter 12 oysters, 6 clams, tuna crudo, shrimp cocktail, 1/2 chilled lobster   65.00


Sautéed Kale garlic, olive oil & sea salt   7.00
Old Bay Fries    6.00
Hush Puppies gouda & chile remoulade   7.00
Sautéed Broccoli Rabe chile flakes & garlic   7.00
Fried Brussels Sprouts bacon & marcona almonds   8.00
Smoked Gouda Mac & Cheese    8.00
Mermaid House Rolls    4.00


Every Sunday

Lobsterpalooza a pound and 1/4 lobster, grilled corn on the cob, red bliss potatoes. limited availability   26.00

Kids $6

Spaghetti with butter or tomato sauce   
Chicken Fingers crispy chicken breast, fries or green salad   
Mac & Cheese mozzarella and parmesean   
Fish Fingers crispy tilapia, fries or green salad   
Quesadilla flour tortillas, melted mozzarella   
Grilled Chicken Breast with fries or green salad   



Tres Leche Challah French Toast strawberries & powdered sugar   12.00
Buttermilk Banana Pancakes vermont maple syrup & powdered sugar   12.00
Eggs Latino corn tortilla, smoked black beans, pickled jalapeño & pico de gallo   14.00
Cast Iron Fritatta broccoli, white cheddar & bacon   13.00
Uws Steak & Organic Eggs grilled hanger steak, eggs any style, herb oil, onion rings   15.00
Eggs Any Style chicken & apple sausage, lyonnaise potatoes & toast   12.00
Smoked Salmon Benedict lyonnaise potatoes, english muffin & old bay hollandaise   15.00

Salads & Sandwiches

Grilled Romaine Salad white anchovies, capers, shaved parmesan & lemon dressing   12.00
Mermaid Black Angus Burger sunny side egg, sautéed vidalia onions, old bay fries   15.00
Seared Tuna Nicoise Salad haricot vert, hard cooked egg & tapenade vinagrette   15.00
Ragin' Cajun Po' Boy shrimp, oysters, griddled broiche, tartar, pico de gallo, cole slaw & fries   16.00
Mermaid Fish Tacos tilapia, marinated red cabbage, pickled jalapeños  ea 7.00
Lobster Sandwich griddled brioche, old bay fries   28.00


Apple Smoked Bacon    6.00
Chicken & Apple Sausage    6.00
Toast    3.00
Old Bay Fries    4.00
Onion Rings    5.00
Seasonal Fruit    6.00
Two Eggs Any Style    4.00
Lyonnaise Potatoes    5.00


Happiest Two Hours

5:00-7:00pm Daily

Raw Bar


Oysters east coast   1.00
west coast   1.75
Littleneck Clams    1.00

Snack Bar

Mini New England Clam Chowder    3.00
Fried Oysters   ea 3.00
Fried Calamari    7.00
Mini Mermaid Fish Taco blackened tilapia, avocado, smoked jalapeno  ea 3.00
Grilled Shrimp & Avocado Slider   ea 8.00
Fried Clam Slider   ea 6.00


Campari Spritz prosecco, campari, cointreau   7.00
The Farmer's Mule farmers gin, fresh lemon, honey   7.00
Mermaid Mary old bay spice, bloody mary mix   7.00
Dark & Stormier gosling's rum, domaine de canton, ginger beer   7.00
Hot And Dirty titos vodka, tobasco, olive, peppadew   7.00
Sparkling Pear pear puree, honey, soda   4.00

Wine By The Glass $6


Beer $5

Pacifico Pilsner    
Smuttynose I.P.A.    



Stone I.P.A. lively hops with lemon & spice (excondido, ca)   7.00
Mendocino Pumpkin Ale robust blend of pumpkin, spice & malt (ukiah, ca)   7.00
Troegs "Dream Weaver" Wheat classic wheat style, floral & citrus notes   7.00
Blue Point Toasted Lager crisp and clean with a balanced bitterness (patchogue, ny)   7.00
Lagunitas Pilsner czech style lager with refreshing spicy hops (petaluma, ca)   7.00
Ithaca Nut Brown Ale nutty, roastes malts and coffee (ithaca, ny)   6.00
Narragansett Lager refreshing lager, mildly sweet and grainy (providence, ri)  (16oz can) 5.00

Beer On Tap $7

Pacifico Pilsner light, crisp and refreshing   
Smuttynose I.P.A. smooth hops with crispy citrus   


Gone With The Gin greenhook gin, grapefruit, rosemary   12.00
The Legend Of Zarro harradura tequila, passion fruit, chipotle, lime   11.00
Dark & Stormier goslings rum, domaine de canton, ginger beer   11.00
Forever In Blue Jeans maker's mark, lemon, spiced fig syrup   13.00
The Berry Gimlet ketel one vodka, raspberry jam, lime   12.00
Hot & Dirty tito's vodka, tobasco, olive, peppadew pepper   12.00
Campari Spritz prosecco, campari, cointreau   11.00
Tommy Collins bulldog gin, q tonic, cucumber, lime   11.00
Mermaid Mary hangar one, old bay spiced mary mix, skewered shrimp   12.00
Sparkling Pear (Non Alcoholic) pear puree, honey, soda   4.00

Wines By The Glass


Brut Cava NV casas del mar (penedes)   9.00
Prosecco Brut NV drusian (veneto)   11.00


Ugni Blanc 2011 domaine de pouy (cotes de gascogne)   9.00
Gruner Veltliner 2012 fritsch (austria)   10.00
Sancerre 2012 la foret (loire)   12.00
Chardonnay 2011 ind. producers (washington)   11.00


Zweigelt 2012 bauer (austria)   9.00


Pinot Noir 2012 rickshaw (california)   11.00
Tempranillo 2011 reynoble (navarra)   10.00
Barbera 2011 cascina (piedmont)   9.00


The Mermaid Inn
568 Amsterdam Ave
Btwn 87th & 88th St
(212) 799-7400
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer