Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

The Counter

  • $$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Burgers
  • 1451 Broadway, New York NY10036 40.755525 -73.986917
  • (Btwn 41st & 42nd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 997-6801
  • 0


Fried Dill Pickle Chips    5.00
Crispy Onion Strings    6.00
French Fries  (sgl order) 3.00 4.50
tillamook cheddar   5.50
Chili Cheese Fries chili, tillamook cheddar, red onion & sour cream   7.00
Parmesan French Fries mixed with parsley, rosemary, & garlic aioli   6.00
Sweet Potato Fries  (sgl order) 3.00 6.00
Chili with tillamook cheddar, red onion & sour cream   6.00
Turkey Chili with cranberries & scallions   6.50
Side Salad lettuce blend or organic mixed greens with red onion, tomato & choice of dressing   4.50
Grilled Vegetables brushed with olive oil   6.00

Starters - The Fifty-Fifty

Fries & Sweet Potato Fries    6.00
Sweet Potato Fries & Crispy Onion Strings    7.00
Fries & Crispy Onion Strings    6.00

Salad Dressings

Apricot Sauce    
Basil Pesto    
Chipotle Aioli    
Classic Caesar    
Country Buttermilk Ranch    
Dijon Balsamic Dressing    
Ginger Soy Glaze    
Honey Mustard    
Horseradish Mayo    
Hot Wing Sauce    
Peanut Sauce    
Red Relish    
Roasted Garlic Aioli    
Russian Dressing    
Spicy Sour Cream    
Steak Sauce    
Sun-Dried Tomato Vinaigrette    
Sweet BBQ Sauce    
Tzatziki Sauce    

Build Your Own Burger

Choose A Burger


Beef   (1/3lb) 10.95
On A Bun    
Chicken   (2/3lb) 12.95
In A Bowl   add 1.00
Turkey   (1lb) 16.95
Lettuce Blend    
Organic Mixed Greens    
Bison   add 4.00
Baby Spinach    

Choose A Cheese

Extra Cheese Add $1.

Danish Blue Cheese    
Herb Goat Cheese Spread    
Soft Ripened Brie    
Horseradish Cheddar    
Tillamook Cheddar    
Greek Feta    
Imported Swiss    
Jalapeño Jack    
Yellow American    
Sharp Provolone    

Choose Up To 4 Toppings

Extra Toppings Add $1.

Baby Spinach    
Dill Pickle Chips    
Lettuce Blend    
Sautéed Onions    
Bermuda Red Onion    
Dried Cranberries    
Marinated Artichokes    
Black Olives    
Fresh Jalapeños    
Organic Mixed Greens    
Sliced Cucumbers    
Carrot Strings    
Grilled Pineapple    
Roasted Corn & Black Bean Salsa    
Spicy Pepperoncinis    
Hard Boiled Eggs    
Roasted Green Chiles    
Roasted Red Peppers    

Premium Toppings $1.50

Per Selection

Applewood Smoked Bacon    
Fried Egg    
Sautéed Mushrooms    
Black Forest Ham    
Fried Onion Strings    
Sun-Dried Tomatoes    
Housemade Guacamole    

Choose A Sauce

Extra Sauce Add $1.

Au Jus    
Country Buttermilk Ranch    
Hot Wing Sauce    
Russian Dressing    
Apricot Sauce    
Dijon Balsamic Dressing    
Lemon Vinaigrette    
Spicy Sour Cream    
Basil Pesto    
Ginger Soy Glaze    
Sun-Dried Tomato Vinaigrette    
Habanero Salsa    
Peanut Sauce    
Sweet BBQ Sauce    
Chipotle Aioli    
Honey Mustard    
Red Relish    
Classic Caesar    
Horseradish Mayo    
Roasted Garlic Aioli    
Tzatziki Sauce    

Choose A Bun

Hamburger Bun    
English Muffin    
Multigrain Bun    
Onion Bun    
Gluten-Free Bun   add 2.00
Rustic Ciabatta    


Signature Burgers

No Additions Or Substitutions.

The Purist all-natural ground beef and a hamburger bun   9.95
Old School 1/3 lb beef, tillamook cheddar, lettuce blend, red onion, pickle, tomato & red relish   10.95
Counter Burger 1/3 lb beef, provolone, crispy onion strings, lettuce blend, sautéed mushrooms & tomato, sun-dried tomato vinaigrette   13.95
Taco Turkey 1/3 lb turkey, jalapeño jack cheese, dried cranberries, lettuce blend, scallions & spicy sour cream   10.95
Unique Veggie 1/3 lb housemade veggie patty, red onion, organic mixed greens, roasted red peppers, sprouts & dijon balsamic   10.95
Grilled Chicken 1/3 lb grilled chicken breast, gruyère, organic mixed greens, scallions, tomatoes & honey mustard   10.95
Mini Cheeseburgers plate of four with tillamook cheddar, pickles, chopped red onion & red relish   10.95

Signature Burgers In A Bowl

No Additions Or Substitutions

Garden Bowl protein of your choice, organic mixed greens, sliced cucumbers, tomatoes, dijon balsamic   10.95
The Counter Cobb 1/3 lb grilled chicken breast, lettuce blend, danish blue cheese, chopped red onion, crumbled bacon, hard boiled eggs, tomatoes & dijon balsamic   13.45
Southwestern 1/3 lb beef, lettuce blend, tillamook cheddar, jalapeños, roasted corn & black bean salsa, roasted green chiles, scallions & classic caesar   11.95
Mediterranean 1/3 lb turkey, lettuce blend, greek feta, black olives, sliced cucumbers, spicy pepperoncinis, tomatoes & tzatziki sauce   11.95
Asian Veggie 1/3 lb housemade veggie patty, organic mixed greens, carrot strings, chopped red onion, grilled pineapple, roasted red peppers, scallions, ginger soy glaze & peanut sauce   11.95
Backyard Barbeque 1/3 lb beef, lettuce blend, horseradish cheddar, black forest ham, chopped red onion, coleslaw, crispy onion strings, scallions, tomatoes, country buttermilk ranch & sweet bbq sauce   14.95


Stacked B.L.T. includes garlic aioli   8.00
Grilled Cheese Trifecta includes tillamook cheddar, american & provolone   7.00
Grilled Ham & Swiss    8.00

Kids Menu

Served With Your Choice Of Either French Fries Or Apple Sauce.

Kids Mini Burgers plate of two with american cheese & pickles   6.00
Kids Grilled Cheese    5.00
Kids Ham & Cheese    6.00
Kids PB&J    5.00


Apple Crumble    5.00
Caramel & Chocolate Brownie    5.00
Key Lime Pie    5.00
Oversize Chocolate Chip Cookie    4.00
Scoop Of Ice Cream    1.75

Shakes, Floats And Malts

Shake apple pie, chocolate, peanut butter, vanilla, black and white, butterscotch, nutella, banana, coffee, strawberry, caramel, cherry.   6.50
add marshmallow.   .50
Birthday Cake Shake vanilla ice cream with cake mix & rainbow sprinkles.   6.50
Banana Split Shake vanilla ice cream with strawberries, banana & caramel, topped with chocolate syrup.   6.50
Caramel Apple Crumble Shake vanilla ice cream with apple crumble & caramel.   6.50
Float coca cola, coke zero, sprite, mr. pibb, ginger ale, diet coca cola, cherry coke, fanta orange, root beer.   5.50
Malt apple, pie, chocolate, peanut butter, vanilla, black and white, butterscotch, nutella, banana, coffee, strawberry, caramel, cherry.   6.50
add marshmallow.   .50


Sodas coca cola, coke zero, sprite, sprite zero, mr. pibb, fanta orange, diet coca cola, cherry coke, diet sprite, ginger ale, root beer, lemonade.   3.75
Teas arnold palmer, sweet tea, fresh iced tea, green tea.   3.75
Water pellegrino, acqua panna.   4.25
Milk milk, kids milk.   3.50
The Counter
1451 Broadway
Btwn 41st & 42nd St
(212) 997-6801
© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.