Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

That's Amore Pizza

  • $
  • American, Italian, Pizza, Sandwiches
  • 1246 Saint Nicholas Ave, NEW YORK 10032 40.84381 -73.937757
  • (Btwn 172nd & 173rd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (917) 791-5035
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 12 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 3_5 Value 3_5
Service 3_5 Atmosphere 3

Other Restaurant Info

(917) 791-5035
Delivery Take-Out Major Credit Cards
Daily: 10am-12am

User Reviews

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Eytan on 2012-05-21

    Food Great, Service Poor

    That's the last time I order from this place and it's a real shame. The food was awesome, but I can never get them to actually take my order. They leave you waiting for 10 minutes, drop your call, and do it over and over again.

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Chris on 2011-02-14


    Only ordered from these guys because my phone was dead, so I had to order online. I've lived in New York my whole life, and I'd be hard pressed to find unappetizing pizza.

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 2010-10-11

    just ok

    just ok. wheres the good pizza in the hieghts?

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Jdiva on 2010-08-02

    Very disappointing!

    I have been living in Washington Heights for the past 6 1/2 years, and have dealt with some bad businesses, and this is one of them. My friend and I ordered the chicken parmesan w/baked ziti and the meatball sub, respectively. The meatball sub was ok,

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Elizabeth on 2010-04-29

    The Best Pizza in NYC

    I have been going to this pizza shop for years and I can honestly recommend it. You haven't had the best pizza if you haven't tried theirs. Their calzones, rolls, pasta dishes and their pizzas are remarkable. Go and try it yourself.

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Brooklyn Teacher on 2010-01-06

    Best Pizza Outside of Brooklyn!

    Hey: We all know that Brooklyn is the King of Pizza! However, there's this little shop located in the Heights called "That's Amore!" In my opinion, the pizza is the best I have ever had. Other people may like the garbage like Dominoes or Pappa John's b

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by pizza lover on 2009-04-20

    Broccoli Pizza

    The pizza itself was pretty mediocre, but good enough. There wasn't enough sauce, but the broccoli on the pizza was really fresh and still kind of crunchy.

  • That's Amore Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 2008-12-05

    Canned mushrooms-ick!

    This just wasn't very good pizza. I ordered a mushroom and fresh tomato pizza and they used CANNED mushrooms - ick! Rubbery, cold and brown. The pizza itself was just O.K., nothing special and I've certainly had better elsewhere. Chicken wings were decent

© 2018 Grubhub, Inc. All rights reserved.