Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Southern & Soul >
Posted by TammyG on 11/18/2007
I ate the catfish and nibbled fried chicken from a family's member plate. I must say the catfish was good along with the fried chicken. I have tried and ate from well-known soul food places in Chicago, Atlanta and LA and none come close to Sylvia's catfish and yams. The yams are to die for, Literally!! I say try it because you definitely have nothing to lose!!
Posted by Anonymous on 06/18/2007
I ordered the fried catfish w/mac & cheese/greens/yams. I've had better catfish, my mom makes better mac & cheese but the greens and yams were on point. This was my first soul food locale and I enjoyed it! The employees were nice & funny and made the trip worth while. Remember you get what you pay for. It is an affordable place so you can't expect a five star quality...if you receive it great.
Posted by Anonymouse on 04/20/2007
I had been a regular at Sylvia's many years ago. Needless to say, I was excited when my nephews expressed interest in going to this NYC landmark. However, the excitement slowly dissipated when the cornbread arrived. It was bland and dry. No amount of butter would have helped. The main entree wasn't any better. The grilled chicken followed the same route. It was also bland and dry. As for the side dishes, I've had better macaroni and cheese and mashed potatoes from a store-bought mix. It was salty and unsatisfying. The service was excellent though. But, what happened to the food? Despite the inadequate meal, my nephews were still excited to be there, but I'm sorry to say that I don't think I'll be visiting Sylvia's again any time soon.
Posted by dee on 04/07/2007
Coming from the midwest with DEEP roots in the south I'm convinced that NY'ers have never had really good soul food (healthy varieties or otherwise). The food I had the ONE time I ever plan to visit Sylvia's was like the one cousin in the family that can't really cook that well but INSISTS on bringing dishes to the potluck. It's not bad... but I can show you good. Good place for a bite if you got to have some fried/greasy/ whatever, but not a must see.
Posted by Decent neighborhood staple on 02/23/2007
The food is decent, but really things like mac and cheese, cornbread, and fried chicken are pretty typical. The best part is the yams. I'd say, on the whole, that I and my guest enjoyed it, but part of what you are paying for is the name. Also, the speakers on Gospel Sundays are cranked way up which makes it hard for you to hear anything else. Also, when they sing Happy Birthday, the gospel singer insists on singing the name of everyone who has a birthday at least 20 times, which is pretty annoying.
Posted by NYC Harlem Foodie on 12/18/2006
Sylvia's has fell WAY OFF. It is touristy and the food is reflective of that. It's just not that good. The good reviews must come from people who have never eaten soul food before.
Posted by Anonymous on 10/27/2006
The best Fried Chicken. Really good Mac and Cheese (but I've had slightly better) Great biscuits, and Greens. I hightly reccommend Sylvia's for Soulfood. Great Value too.