Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Sutton Pizza and Gyro

  • $$$
  • Italian, Pizza
  • 1140 1st Ave, New York 10065 40.761803 -73.960159
  • (Btwn 62nd & 63rd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (646) 582-6915
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 22 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 4 Value 4
Service 4 Atmosphere 3

Other Restaurant Info

(646) 582-6915
Major Credit Cards
Daily: 11am-12am
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Delivery, Lunch, Online Ordering, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by Tracy sims on 2014-02-24

    Great spot! Great service. Nyc pizza at its best

    Get at least once a week. Pick up, order in, or delivery has always been perfect. Very family friendly and great staff! If I could Id give 6 stars.

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by Mellissa on 2013-06-13

    love this place!

    NEVER lets me down! We come to New York monthly and this is hands down the best pizza! And the service is not to be forgotten- my daughter and I traveled to NYC recently and I had a stroller...which is tough to get through doorways, but they even went s

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by Kevin on 2013-05-28

    Great food, poor service

    Excellent food, gyros are great, pizza is fresh, pasta is terrific but the service is poor. They barely take your order and act like its a favor for them to even serve you But in a neighborhood with few good pizza options it's the price to pay but it does

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by richard on 2012-06-18

    Been ordering for over 20 years

    Can't beat it....their baked ziti and pizza are the greatest. They are one of the few establishments left in the neighborhood. I have never been disappointed with.. Keep that homemade cooked all day sauce coming. Thanks.

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by disappointed on 2011-11-07

    Not recommended

    I wanted to try the food here but when i called for delivery (after the phone rang forever) i was told they would not deliver to me because i was a block out of their area. I live 10 blocks away from this location and they couldnt go half a block up to de

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by Hw on 2011-09-13

    Best slice on UES

    Great local pizza place. Excellent pizza and outstanding service. A local must.

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by Anonymous on 2009-07-02

    Pizza Pizza!

    Wouldnt go anywhere else!.. Great pizza! I love this place!

  • Sutton Pizza and Gyro

    Posted by GreatFoodSeeker on 2009-06-24

    Great quality food with not a lot of taste

    The food was excellent quality. Only problem was, it didn't exactly have a lot of flavor. If you like slightly above average flavor, but large quantities, this is your place. If you are looking for gyros that taste "American" not Greek, this is your pla

© 2018 Grubhub, Inc. All rights reserved.