Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown East >
Diners & Coffee Shops >
Posted by DiningDeacon on 12/06/2012
Sutton is an old-fashioned New York Greek diner. An authentic one, not an ironic one. A dependable faded neighborhood place. The food is solid for its kind, the service efficient and pleasantly brash.
Posted by ADP on 04/13/2011
We came here because the reviews were overall pretty good. However, the food was just OK. The salad was fresh, but chicken a little dry. Service was poor and they charge an extra dollar just for credit card transactions. I wont be back.
Posted by MH on 03/10/2009
Service was so sloooow. Food is okay for the price. It's just a diner with a no rush attitude.
Posted by eastsider on 11/18/2007
everything about this place is weak...except the food. Service was poor, atmosphere (you'll smell like grease when you leave) was lacking...but the food is great. other 1st ave diners are way overpriced...order out and have some tasty grub.
Posted by Anonymous on 03/09/2007
I love the cheese fries there, so i dont know what the person before me was talking about...the greek salad is exceptional ( i prefer mine chopped there) you really cant go wrong if youre looking for a diner menu, everything i have had there has always been excellent. i am a foodie, so take my word.
Posted by hmm on 12/06/2004
Went here the other day. The place was clean, service was OK, but a bit grumpy. Food is certainly edible, and you won't leave hungry, but a few things struck me as odd. Hot tea refills - they expect you to re-use the Lipton tea bag for a second cup Orange Juice - just plain bad; not fresh squeezed, not even Tropicana, more like fountain OJ from concentrate Cheese Fries - Literally, a plate of shoestring fries with a piece of American cheese tossed on top, half melted. Omelet - overcooked
Posted by Burger McBurgerton on 08/09/2004
This place is like any other dinner in town except their burgers are addictive. Very greasy and a pretty good size. Their delivery is fast and reliable. Fries are good as well...