Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Midtowner on 05/21/2009
I am usually wary of Times Square restaurants but tried St. Andrews because of the good reviews here. I was very disappointed. We were there for dinner on 5/20 and decided to have the daily special – Porterhouse with wine reduction which came with mashed potatoes and collards. The steak was completely inedible as it was all gristle, sinews, and, fat plus it was really tough. Not only were the steaks poor cuts of meat but they were poorly cooked too. We ordered medium and medium-rare but there was no difference that we could see. The sauce looked like gravy rather than a reduction. Potatoes and collards were fine, but expensive given that we paid $29 for the entrée and could only eat the vegetables.
Posted by anonymous on 05/02/2009
I have visited this restaurant many times and the food and service is always outstanding! The baby back ribs are excellent as is their steak. You can expect large portions at a very reasonable price, especially for New York City. Bar drinks are also of a nice size and a fair price. They have remodeled it since my last visit so I do not know how much has changed. All I know it was excellent all the times I have been there.
Posted by kppm on 01/23/2009
A NYC bargain the wine dinner... choose any appetizer, entree and dessert with cofffe and 4 wines - all you can drink. All under $50 Tracy is The BEST. Try to have her as your waitress. I take all my out of town friends (as well as those here in th ecity).
Posted by Jennie Belle on 12/17/2008
I love going to St. Andrews. It's my favorite resturant in NYC along with my best friend. We found the resturant by accident four years ago and we have been going there there ever since. My friend ravs about the haggis. I love the Caesar Salad and Cranagan. But all in all I have never had a bad meal there. The atmosphere and service is great. You are made feel like family.
Posted by long islander may 1st 2008 on 05/03/2008
great food /service our server was tracy and she was the best!! everything about this restaurant was perfect!!! we all had the pre fix ,great value 29.95 soup or salad only three entrees (wish there was more of a selection) but all three were great ,dessert and coffee! these reviews really help so go with them and trust us!! laura and justin the mangers were also GREAT!! def.will go back!!
Posted by mary, from vancouver on 04/08/2008
my husband and another couple (all ex pats living in Vancouver) visited new york last week and came across st. andrews on our wanderings. the food is delish and the service from Elspeth was lovely. definately recommending it and will return when we are next back in NY. from someone who knows her haggis, the homemade haggis at st. andrews is excellent and if you go there you absolutely have to try it. we all felt like we were back in bonnie scotland!
Posted by outtatowner on 02/05/2008
I have been going to St. Andrews for a few years now whenever I happen to be arouund that part of town or am going to a show. I have always loved the food, especially the Buffalo Calamari, and the drink selection is totally awesome. On my last trip in there though I barely knew any of the staff, my 2 favourite Scottish bartenders, Sharon & Roger have gone back to Scotland and my favourite friendly waitress has gone back to Ireland! Maybe I need to move over that part of the pond too!!