Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

South Brooklyn Pizza (CLOSED)

  • $$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza
  • 122 1st Ave, New York NY10009 40.72707 -73.985288
  • (Btwn St Marks Pl & 7th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 533-2879
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 14 reviews)

Food 4.3 Value 3.8
Service 4.6 Atmosphere 4.2

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 533-2879
Place Order:
Order From South Brooklyn Pizza for delivery & takeout
Delivery Take Out Major Credit Cards
Daily: 11am-5am
Lunch, Dinner
Trendy, Delivery, Online Ordering, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out

User Reviews

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by Tried em' all on 01/28/2014

    Will settle this for both sides

    This is high-end gourmet pizza. It's top notch, fresh ingredients, Italian style, amazing pizza! It's also $4 a slice, which you know going in. If you compare it to $1/slice places, it's expensive, if that's your palate and you don't care what you eat. If you want quality or to try some of the best pizza in the city - give it a shot, yes, even for the price, I promise you'll be back.

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by foodbro on 04/13/2013

    Favorite pizza in the Galaxy

    Truth. Bring your wallet.

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by Pamie on 07/12/2012


    Four dollars a slice is about two and a half times what this is worth. Chintzy on the cheese, stingy on the sauce, the crust was doughy and overblown. Won't be back. Gosh, I wish there was a decent pizza place in this part of the East Village. This sure is NOT it.

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by Septemous on 10/03/2011

    Top Slice

    Yes it's pricey - but if you compare to the garbage ingredients that Two Boots puts out for .25 cents less, well it's not that pricey. As my friend said - and summed it up - "This is the best pizza I've had outside Italy". Eat it there, as they pies don't last long enough to become cold or stale. Always warm and Fresh. The Garlic topping & Hot Peppers are superb!

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by jordan on 12/28/2010

    Amazing pie, but at what price?

    Look, its great. It really is. Crust, cheese, sauce, the fresh garlic. You have to try it. But come on, its just too darn expensive. $28 a pie? Nuts.

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by TommyTheTooth on 12/01/2010

    Not worth the price

    $28 for a regular pie is highway robbery. No matter how fresh the incredients are. I could not believe the price. The pizza looked amazing when I picked it up. The Italian man even added some olive oil and a touch of basil before closing the lid. After a 10 min walk home the pizza was ICE cold and the bottom was completely burnt. I was very sad. I would try it again if the prices came down. Really $28 for a regular pizza pie ? Who are you kidding!

  • South Brooklyn Pizza

    Posted by gobbledygoo on 11/28/2010

    i am obsessed

    so good. just try it already. you won't be disappointed ... ;)

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.