Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Eastern European, Seafood, Sandwiches
  • 141 Court St, Brooklyn NY11201 40.683125 -73.992485
  • (Btwn Pacific St & Atlantic Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (718) 855-8817
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 4 reviews)

Food 3.1 Value 3.3
Service 3.4 Atmosphere 4.1

Other Restaurant Info

(718) 855-8817
Major Credit Cards
Tue-Fri: 8am-7pm Sat: 8am-6pm Sun: 8am-4pm
Accepts Credit Cards, Lunch, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

    Posted by Lainie on 03/25/2015

    Makes me love my neighborhood.

    This is the real deal. Outstanding fish, classic appetizing an exciting new ideas (the bluefish salad with orange fennel and hazelnuts... HellOOOO, Gorgeous!). The folks in there are so cool and so nice. I'm easily in there once a week. Do yourself a favor and get your tushie over there. (The Gatsby is by far my fave sandwich)

  • Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

    Posted by L Port on 11/15/2014

    Disappointment... So much potential

    Shelsky's in theory could be a good addition to the neighborhood, as it would be great to not have to go to fairway to get my weekly smoked salmon. But... The first time I went, I came home and half of my sliced salmon was brown and there was hard parts on it. The next few times I asked if they could trim (like at Fairway) and yet every time, I come home and there is brown, fishy edges (even though they cut a little out) and I have to spend my time cleaning it up. I also find that if I ask for half a pound, I get closer to 3/4, or 1/4, I get a third. Going to Fairway is worth the trip- where you get consistently pristine, professionally sliced salmon. Ps. Always get a receipt because 2 times I was overcharged!

  • Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

    Posted by brklnCarroll on 05/27/2012


    The food is good. So glad to have a smoked fish shop this good in Carroll Gardens.

  • Shelsky's Of Brooklyn

    Posted by Ian on 10/18/2011

    Only authentic appetizing in area

    Great variety of high-quality smoked fish and other traditional Ashkenazi Jewish cuisine. The bagels are delicious, but not baked in-house, so on Saturdays they have been frozen from the day before. They slice fish to-order which is classy, but painstaking, so if you're looking for a quick in-and-out bagel you'll be disappointed. If you're new to appetizing (the dairy flip-side of delicatessen), they are very happy to guide.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.