Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Sandwich Shoppe

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Sandwiches
  • 58A Greenwich Ave, New York NY10011 40.735977 -74.000595
  • (Btwn 6th & 7th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 255-2237
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 10 reviews)

Food 4.3 Value 4.2
Service 4.0 Atmosphere 3.4

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 255-2237
Place Order:
Order From Sandwich Shoppe for delivery & takeout
Delivery Take Out MC, Visa, AmEx
Mon-Sat: 7am-10pm Sun: 8am-8pm
Breakfast, Dinner
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Lunch, Online Ordering, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by Wade on 06/16/2014

    Still the best

    I'm a 20 year customer, been going since Elementary school (ps41 next door). The location has changed but the food is still great. The turkey is fresh roasted (think thanksgiving) and juicy. The fried chicken is amazing. The cuban is so flavorful. With all the timeout new york restaurants in the hood selling trendy specialty meatballs and ramen burgers this sandwich shop will survive based on quality alone. This is one of the last true family owned and operated business in the village.

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by NYCSANDWICHGIRL on 01/28/2010

    Village history

    This sandwich store has been around for years, delivering always high quality foods. The 'new' owner previously mentioned is actually the sister of the original brother owners. They keep it all in the family. She actually started most of the recipes. FUN FACT! YUUUUMMMMMYYYY!

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by Neighborhood Customer on 06/06/2009

    Never again

    it took over an hour to get a sandwich delivered. i live 2 blocks away. i should have walked over to get it but just wanted it delivered. no matter what, it should take under 70 minutes to deliver a sandwich 2 blocks. it's 2:25 in the afternoon. not exactly the busiest time of day. sandwich was fine, but not worth an absurd amount of time.

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by Earl of Sandwich on 01/05/2008

    Stale Bread - Not What It Used to Be

    This place was a gem when it was operated by the original owners under the simple name Sandwiches. It was two guys who were very funny who made the sandwiches and always kidded with you. They obviously sold the place, which now has nondescript types working there. I agree with poster below about the herb mayo - absolutely delicious on everything. But the quality has greatly diminished. I was here last week and the bread was stale. I should have suspected something when I was asked if I wanted it toasted - never a good sign. For almost $8.00, I got a mediocre sandwich on old bread. Feh! I will never go back.

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by MV on 10/25/2007

    Great Herbal Mayo at TOSS

    The only place on earth that has this great unique herbal mayo. I highly recommend it. I have this mayo on all the sandwiches I get at TOSS. It is just deliciously addicting. Thanks guys!

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/08/2007

    great turkey sandwiches... if only...

    i keep coming back for their fresh dark-meat turkey sandwiches, and as i eat them, i always yearn for cranberry sauce, gravy or stuffing to go on it! the only reason this sandwich doesn't get a perfect rating is that it comes so close to that classic one... i recommend that people check it out, and casually ask the server if they have cranberry sauce.... maybe they'll get the hint!

  • Sandwich Shoppe

    Posted by Jake on 01/13/2007

    Best Sandwichs Ever: Quality & Service!

    The guys at The Original Sandwich Shoppe (T.O.S.S.). make the best sandwichs ever! The attention to detail and quality at TOSS is unheard of for a sandwich shop. I have been eating at TOSS since I was a young boy and I love everything I have ever eaten. The fresh carved turkey sandwich is by far my favorite. The meat is alway fresh-off-the-bone and the herbal mayonnaise is distinct and delicious. Ask for honey mustard and they will mix fresh honey and their textured mustard to suite your tastes. For a little extra kick you can request spicy chipotle mayonnaise. The soups are great during the cold winter months. My other recommendations include the marinated steak sandwich, their fresh squeezed juices, and the "mama's fried breaded chicken' sandwich. I strongly urge everyone to try the food at TOSS.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.