Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Sal & Carmine's Pizza
Posted by Anonymous on 09/07/2010
The absurd amount of salt makes one wonder about the freshness (or lack thereof) of ingredients. This greasy salt slab may be the worst slice in Manhattan.
Posted by Pizzaman on 04/23/2010
So I walked past this joint and noticed that the Health Dept shut it down. I do not know how long they closed them down for. Don't even want to think about what they found but this place has gone downhill over the past couple of years. Too expensive!!
Posted by Shuki on 01/22/2010
This is by far the best pizza in the neighborhood. Yes, it is a little pricey, but it's worth it for the amazing pizza. If you're looking for a slice or two, you HAVE to go here!
Posted by Anonymous on 12/14/2009
I thought I was the only one who thought the pizza there was too salty. It is too salty by my taste buds. Too bad since it is very close to where I recently moved. If they could just lay off the salt I would love to call it my regular
Posted by PizzaExpert on 08/12/2009
It has been several months since I have been in this pizza place. I would stop by every so often as the pizza was pretty good, athough a bit salty. I know pizza well, been so hundreds of places around the city. When I walked in there the other day, I could not believe a plain slice was 3 bucks. Thats insane! There is a place in the w.70s that got me a bit mad when they charged 2.75 but 3 dollars? Besides, the slices seem like they got a bit smaller. Not worth it!!! They have some nerve charging that amount, especially for a place above 86th st. Also, a large pie is $24. They dont even discount for 8 slices. They will surely lose customers soon.
Posted by Anonymous on 07/03/2009
I grew up around the block from this place so obviously I am slightly biased but let me say this, what makes it a truly great slice is the taste of it, see the cheese and sauce they use have a totally different taste then other slices. the dough they use is sooooo great. I cant explain why the slice tastes so unique just go.
Posted by MS on 06/03/2009
RIP Sal. Your Pizza will be missed.