MenuPages

I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant. Their food and service is top notch and my friends and family are all return customers. Locals are usually at the bar and its a feel good place to go to eat, drink or just chill. From steak to seafood their food is consistently cooked to perfection. They have a great lunch and they have the best lobster rolls. Service is with a smile and you will feel like you are part of their family.

Very good food and the waiters, bartenders and staff were all so pleasant. This kind of place makes you smile because everyone working is smiling and energetic. Not to mention, the filet mignon was cooked to perfection. Will definitely come back!

We ordered lunch for the office and the food was great! They delivered in a timely manner and the staff was very content with their individual orders. We will definitely order from here in the future!

We dined at Sagaponack last night and left disappointed because of the overcooked seafood. The crabcakes were nicely done - although the crab did not stand out as the star ingredient. The scallop appetizer was also somewhat disappointing when two small, but nicely seared scallops arrived. I wouldn't bother ordering the salads. The lobster roll was the best menu choice - but still doesn't warrant a visit back to the restaurant. The most disappointing selection was the bucatini with mixed seafood. Every single piece was overcooked and tough. The mussels were of poor quality and the shrimp were inexcusably dry. On the plus side - the staff was personable and attentive.

Went with a group of coworkers. The downstairs decor has a good theme but the upstairs is a little confusing with the bright lights and 80s apohlstery. The food was very hotel food like. The oysters were tasteless and the lobster mac and cheese had only a few pieces of lobster in it. The turbot was obviously a frozen piece of fish. The one shining light was the management staff that were very accomodating and friendly

Really not good. the Korean beef in my taco was mostly fat and little flavor. they were tiny as well, a small sliver of meat. the chips were beyond greasy and the Guac sub-par. The lemonade was so watered down it was pathetic. Not recommended at all. All for a not so inexpensive price. Skip it

Had lunch here with two colleagues and we all had lobster rolls. Great value - lots of lobster, and the the pesto shoestring fries were great! Brioche buns not my favorite, but ymmv. Small place, but good for talking. Terrific service. I'd go again.