Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Sagaponack Restaurant

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (New), Seafood
  • 4 W 22nd St, New York NY10010 40.74155 -73.99168
  • (Btwn 5th & 6th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 229-2226
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 22 reviews)

Food 3.9 Value 3.7
Service 4.0 Atmosphere 4.2

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 229-2226
Happy Hour Mon-Fri: 4:30pm-6:30pm Major Credit Cards
Mon-Thu: 11:30am-3pm+5:30pm-11pm Fri: 11:30am-3pm+5:30pm-12am Sat: 11am-4pm+5:30pm-12am Sun: 11am-4pm
Brunch, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Bar Scene, Catering, Delivery, Happy Hour, Kid Friendly, Online Reservations, Private Parties, Raw Bar, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible

User Reviews

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by Terry on 09/13/2013

    No one cares!

    1. Friendly staff. 2. Inept server. Why? Where are the oysters from? Answer: Long Island. WRONG. Malpeques are from Nova Scotia. This touts itself as a real deal seafood restaurant. Know the menu! 3. Ordered 12 oysters got 6 and had to reorder the other 6. 4. Everyone's salad/appetizer came at the same time as their entree. 5. Server's pen ran out while taking the order and "I've got a great memory" turned out to one of us getting the wrong dinner. 6. DON'T EVER BLAME THE ERRORS ON A COMPUTER GLITCH! We were 4 out of 12 in a 50+ capacity restaurant. YOU were the glitch! 8. Is that pinot noir from Oregon? Answer: Yes Coastal Valley. WRONG! It's California!!! 7. Manager who really didn't seem to care at all when problems were brought to his attention ingenuously offered free desserts. Overall... Will never come back. Flavor: Mediocre at best Atmo: Eh Service: Dumb at best Cost: Still paying as I am still apologizing to my guests who I enthusiastically brought here. Summation: Whomever owns this place takes no pride in what or how food being served. Is this some sort of tax write off for you? You obviously don't care.

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by foodfan on 04/26/2013

    Great place

    It's not Le Bernardin, but it's as good a seafood place of its own American/East End kind as you'll get in Manhattan.You'll like the chowder, lobster rolls, crab cakes, tuna nicoise, all in a cheerful seaside setting. Good wine and beer list and friendly servers. I can't wait to go back.

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by Anonymous on 05/24/2012

    What a disappointment

    Food was mediocre at best and overpriced for what it was. Caesar salad was soggy and not a sardine to be seen. Crab bisque was salty and watery. Crab cakes were sorely lacking in crab and overrun with bread as filling. Lobster roll bun wasn't even toasted. Portion sizes are nice and service was good although a bit hard to understand at times. I wouldn't go back

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by Foodie on 03/21/2012

    Such a great restaurant!

    Great food & the service could not have been more friendly! So refreshing to have a great meal & wonderful service. Will definitely be back for lunch & dinner.

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by Eileen Millan on 11/06/2011

    My favorite restaurant

    I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant. Their food and service is top notch and my friends and family are all return customers. Locals are usually at the bar and its a feel good place to go to eat, drink or just chill. From steak to seafood their food is consistently cooked to perfection. They have a great lunch and they have the best lobster rolls. Service is with a smile and you will feel like you are part of their family.

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by Edward K on 11/04/2011

    Delicious and Friendly

    Very good food and the waiters, bartenders and staff were all so pleasant. This kind of place makes you smile because everyone working is smiling and energetic. Not to mention, the filet mignon was cooked to perfection. Will definitely come back!

  • Sagaponack Restaurant

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/25/2011

    Great Service and Great Food

    We ordered lunch for the office and the food was great! They delivered in a timely manner and the staff was very content with their individual orders. We will definitely order from here in the future!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.