Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Podunk

  • $$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Teahouses, Sandwiches
  • 231 E 5th St, New York NY10003 40.727299 -73.989614
  • (Btwn 2nd & 3rd Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 677-7722
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 9 reviews)

3.975
Food 4.3 Value 3.4
Service 3.7 Atmosphere 4.4

Other Restaurant Info

Phone:
work
(212) 677-7722
Notes:
Major Credit Cards
Hours:
Daily: 11am-9pm
Serves:
Lunch, Dinner
Features:
Accepts Credit Cards

User Reviews

  • Podunk

    Posted by Nicole on 02/22/2012

    I want to live here

    I can't get enough of Podunk. I take two subways to get here even though I live walking distance from Alice's. The baked treats are always incredibly fresh and delicate. The petite scones and homemade jam and cream are the best I've ever had. The cupcakes are the best in the city. They take great care to offer fresh and high-quality food, and it's worth every penny. Love this place. If you have very high standards like I do, you won't be disappointed.

  • Podunk

    Posted by Anonymous on 07/23/2010

    Charming…

    …but overpriced.

  • Podunk

    Posted by EastVillage OldTimer on 12/24/2009

    High Tea Is Low Meal

    First off, I wish to heaven that people would get it straight: "high tea" is not the fancy scones-and-tea meal ignorant Americans think it is. High tea is a low meal: working-class supper. Meat, a veg or two, maybe a sweet dessert, a cuppa tea. That's it. You people mean "AFTERNOON" tea when you rave on about the scones and the clotted cream and the jam and the tiny sandwiches. Geez. Get it right. That said, this place is great. I do think it's a bit pricey for what it offers---you can do way better pricewise for tea at other places---but it's fun, clean and convenient.

  • Podunk

    Posted by Arthur V. on 07/10/2009

    As if the whole world was suddenly a small town

    I'm probably not a typical tea person but my girlfriend of three years wanted to have tea in the city after we booked a trip to London, where I spent a summer a long time ago. We walked around to various places, and ended up at Podunk, first because Tea and Sympathy was so crowded for brunch, and second because Alice's Tea is too far away and a little, well, fey. The ten tables or so were mostly filled, so we squeezed into a bench by the cash register, and watched all of humanity go by. Neighbors came in for scones and cupcakes, the UPS man scored some chocolate chip cookies--very friendly. We ordered a rustic tea for two, less than 20 bucks each. While we waited other people paid for their tea or ordered and it was lively and sort of fun, because I remember tea rooms as being kind of hushed and serious. We were comfortable, happy with the food, and pleased by the unexpected people-watching opportunity. The woman at the counter, though always in motion, is the queen of comebacks and snappy lines. I can see how people might read her differently, but I was charmed. Our plates of food were eyefilling and stomach-filling, with savory cheese and warm bread, special dipping sauces, olives and veggies, and tea, and cookies. We'll go back soon.

  • Podunk

    Posted by anonymous on 02/10/2009

    Way Over-Priced

    $23.90 for two mini scones and two pots of tea, they were not even fancy teas; a plain herbal tea and a chai! Ouch. A beautiful quaint madly overpriced tea house...

  • Podunk

    Posted by anonymous on 05/11/2008

    Best little tea shop in the world

    Podunk is the best little tea shop in the whole world. I have never written a review for any restaurant before and didn't want to really write one for this either (mostly because I don't want my favorite tea place run over by horrible EVillage tourists) but I feel like this place deserves every little bit of credit it can get. Elsabeth, who runs the place, makes everything from scratch and bakes her goodies daily. The scones and pies are to die forso fresh and moist, you could be in Scotland for cream tea and scones. I can't believe the people who complain about the price, especially considering that they would think nothing of dropping $50 on sub-par food at crappy restaurants in the neighborhood. Maybe its a cultural thingPodunk is a place you should go to have "high tea"where you go to socialize with friends over a nice pot of perfectly brewed Orange Pekoe as you nibble on delicious snacks, not some sleazy American cafe chain where you get a mini diaper filled with half dead tea leaves floating in luke warm water in a styrofoam cup. All in allif you know good tea and if you know the traditions of high tea make haste and go to Podunkyou wont be disappointed!

  • Podunk

    Posted by Anonymous on 03/02/2008

    Calm Tea Setting, Yummy Scones

    My mother and I visited Podunk for the first time on a late Friday afternoon. It was quite chilly outside, so it was a nice stop for a bit of late lunch and tea. The atmosphere is the best part...With mismatched chairs & tables, old ice skates hanging on the wall, vintage bookshelves, I feel like I'm sipping tea with some characters out of "Little Women", only in a more relaxed, funkier place. The space is light, airy, bright, with lots of natural light coming in from the window. This is not Alice's Tea Cup, where there are long lines, chaos, and lots of food on the menu. This is more mom & pop. You find a seat, plop down, and then go up to the counter to place your order. When your order is ready, the woman who owns the place will call you up to retrieve your goodies. I know a lot of people say they were yelled at by this woman, and people vow to never return. However, she was incredibly nice. It was only when the woman sitting behind me began to talk ridiculously loudly on her cell phone, that the owner walked towards the counter and gave her a threatening glare, before the loud cell-phone talker finally walked outside to continue her conversation. I can understand how it must be difficult for the owner to deal with people like this all day, every day..especially since she put in the effort to post a sign, asking people not to speak on cell phones when inside her establishment. I think this rule is great when visiting tea shops..I go there to relax, to study, to read a book, and to enjoy the quiet. I would definitely go back. The only issue I had was that there doesn't seem to be many lunch/ sandwich selections. At least not vegetarian options. The cucumber sandwiches were good - but it is just cucumbers with butter. I do wish they would add a hummus sandwich. The tea was probably the best tea I've ever tasted (and I've been to many, many tea shops around NYC). You should try it..Toasted Green Vanilla. Perhaps it is because all of their tea is loose-leaf tea, and I'm so used to drinking tea made with tea bags. Whatever it was, this tea was so fresh, so tasty, we had 2 pots..and still craved a 3rd as we walked out the door. And ah, the scones. So delicious.. The owner had made many varieties, and we tried almost every single one. The plain is delicious, but try the coconut-apricot. Yummy! Plus, there was also a big layout of other tasty goods.. homemade cookies, focaccia breads, cakes...

Advertising
3,000+ menus from the world's most diverse neighborhood.
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer