Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Village/ W Village >
Posted by West Village Resident on 05/12/2014
This review is for the jerk chicken, stew chicken, and the curry chicken, Jamaican staples that Pluck U doesn't seem to be known for. In a word, the chicken over rice and beans plates are STELLAR. There are a number of options for this kind of Jamaican food, even in this neighborhood, but of all the places I've tried, Pluck U does these dishes best. The caveat: I've never tried wings of any sort, there; the chicken and beef patties are just so-so (a bit rubbery from being reheated); and the sandwiches I've tried were meh. I go to Pluck U strictly for the chicken plates and have so far always left happy. Delivery estimates on Seamlessweb are accurate for this restaurant. I think it's usually from 45 to 60 minutes.
Posted by Nick on 12/11/2013
Steak sandwhich was awful and the fingers were pretty unappetizing too.
Posted by Sam on 12/19/2012
Have been a loyal customer for years. Ordered over the weekend. To say I was disappointed does not even touch the surface. Chicken bland. Best blue cheese in the world no more. What happened!?!?!? Will not be ordering again. Very sad. Very sad indeed....
Posted by iamcandijay on 09/02/2012
I had the honey mustard wings and they were just plain wings with Ken's Honey Mustard on the side. Very boring...and came with 3 pieces of celery, one of which was brown. The bleu cheese that came with the celery was actually very tasty! I might give this place one more try if it's on someone elses dime.
Posted by Anonymous on 03/05/2012
Eating at the place is great even though it's tiny, but getting it delivered is frustrating. The fries came mushy and the wings were cold... But the wings here are definetly above average
Posted by Big Mike on 11/11/2011
I live/work 2 blocks away from Pluck U. Not only did it take 35 minutes for my boneless wings and fries to arrive. They were ice cold and nasty when they finally did.With no utensils and condiments in sight. I have been ordering from here for the past 6 years and have noticed a steady decline in the quality and care with which food is prepared. I will probably not order from here again
Posted by chenz on 02/07/2010
definitely expected better, especially on superbowl sunday. when i ordered i was excited...just by the name. i waited 2.5 hours for a delivery and the cost was too much for the dry burned baby chickwing delights i got. the bleu cheese did not taste good. when i finally got the pluck u delivery i was already like pluck you pluck u but i had to taste the wings for myself and once i put one in my mouth i instantly regretted my tip to the delivery guy. needless to say id rather be chewing on bacon bits. my mouth is traumatized. the meat was dryer than the sahara desert and the texture was as crusty. the medium sauce was tangy and not at all medium, actually more like eating a sourpatch with molasses on it. the only good thing is that the 3 celery sticks that i paid .50 cents extra for were the most delicious stalks of veges in my day.