MenuPages

The Buffalo wings WERE the best in Brooklyn hands down. The honey BBQ wings were something I would order 2-3 times a week and never cared that they were expensive because they were awesome. Now they water down the honey bbq sauce and act like no one will notice. These are the types of moves that places make and wind up going out of business because of it. Seriously, its like they don't like money, what a disgrace.

Sad to see what happened to this place. They've alienated one customer base after the next. One can only hope that the process of creative destruction will drive these owners out of the business and let someone else try to bring the place back up to speed.

I have ordered the hot wings countless of times and have nothing but great things to say. Great flavor and the wings are very meaty. Tried the honey garlic and those were terrible. Stick to the hot wings and you won't be disappointed.

This place used to be great - great location, atmosphere, character, bar, menu. It was the kind of place perfect for a burger & beer on a lazy weekend, in a beautiful neighborhood. But then they decided to fill the once fabulous old-world style bar with not one but FOUR large screen TV's all blaring at high volume, replaced all the comfortable tables and chairs with small patio furniture, and changed the menu to high-priced, low-quality non-traditional bar food. It's as if the owners of P.J. Hanley's wished they owned a stadium instead of the lovely, historic place it is. What a shame. After a couple very dissatisfying visits, we have decided never to return, and to encourage our friends to follow suit.

I was at Hanley's recently and I ordered a round. The bartender said $12. I gave her a $20. She brought me back $5 and walked away. I called her over to ask why and she said "Oh, I don't have any singles." No appology, nothing. Are they just plain trying to steal my money? Also if you want your drinks on the rocks, they will charge you an extra dollar!! Outrageous!

Absolutely true about downhill service and raised prices. Its incredibly disappointing considering this was a neighborhood staple. The last time I went, the service was so unacceptable that I decided I wasn't going back. I do not recommend this place.

This place has gone completely downhill as of recent. The service has always been slow but the food was worth the wait. Now the prices have gone up significantly and there is no consistency with the staff.