Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Upper West Side >
Posted by Anonymous on 01/24/2014
Best pizza on the UWS! Must go!
Posted by UWSer on 08/01/2012
This is our favorite pizza place (ever since it changed ownership about 6 or 7 years ago - before that it was disappointing). When its good and fresh its amazing. On rare occasion they have an off night and its mediocre, but its still worth going back again. The atmosphere is a hole in the wall but its worth stopping in. The guys that work there are really nice - especially nice to our children who love them and love going there.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/25/2012
After living on the UWS for a few years I'm glad I randomly tried this place. Good Pizza at a fair price, even passed the carry out test without becoming a soggy mess! I'll be stopping in again for sure.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/08/2012
Ordered pizza last week and was finally impressed by an UWS slice! Ordered tonight and i knew the person taking the order was going to get the order wrong after repeating it three times. On top of it, he was rude. And the person who delivered didn't seem to know the difference between diet coke and coke. And the sub roll was burned and inedible. Calzone was mediocre. Overall we are not impressed.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/02/2012
Pizza Pete's is definitely my go-to place in the neighborhood. It's the best pizza I've tasted for it's price! I like the physical place for a casual snack. My one complaint is that the workers are a bit sleazy. So, food-wise it's a #1 choice, great for a casual lunch/snack, but discomforting workers!
Posted by NYC Pizza connoisseur on 01/02/2012
I have lived in Manhattan for a little over three years now and this is bar far and away the best pizza in New York City. Lombardi's is a close second, but no line/ wait/ and better price! This is it for New York Pizza!
Posted by anonymous on 06/22/2011
what happened to pizza petes? it used to be so so so good and delivery was always quick and easy. what happened ? Last two times I have ordered they forgot about my order then told me an hour later when i called that they had forgotten, then decided to rush and make a pizza (not fully cooked) and deliver it. thanks pizza pete! you lost me as a costumer and i will be sure to spread the word!