Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Pintailes Pizza

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza, Wings
  • 1573 York Ave, NEW YORK NY10028 40.774433 -73.948474
  • (Btwn 83rd & 84th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 396-3479
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 35 reviews)

Food 3.5 Value 2.9
Service 3.3 Atmosphere 3.3

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 396-3479
(212) 722-1967
Free Delivery Take Out Extended Hours Vary With The Seasons Visa, MC, AmEx
Daily: 11am-9:30pm
Lunch, Dinner
Delivery, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out
Min Delivery:
Delivery Area:
5th Ave to East River; 64th St to 97th

User Reviews

  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by Patty on 04/16/2013


    I ordered a small pizza to go. The pizza was like cardboard. The cheese looked shriveled and peeled off the pizza when picking up each slice. I can only figure I was given a pizza that was laying around for hours. Never again !!

  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 02/08/2013

    Poor Quality Chicken!

    I ordered a Chicken Parm Hero today and when I got home I discovered that the quality of chicken is perhaps the poorest I've seen. Anywhere. I don't even want to imagine what part of the bird it came from. It was rubbery and slimy. I had to throw the whole sandwich out, which means $7.56 in the trash. I'll never go here again.

  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by Tom on 10/20/2012

    Never Again

    I ordered 6 wings and the Mesc. salad with chicken to go. When I got there, the only person capable of ringing me up was on the phone and did not acknowledge me. Someone threw 2 bags on the counter but I wasn't sure if those were mine so I waited. The girl finally got off the phone and rang me up. $20 seemed like too much so I asked and she said the wings were $10. I said fine and left. I checked the menu on the walk back and discovered I was right but after inspecting my order realized that's because they gave me 12 wings not the 6 I ordered. Full disclosure, I said 6 so there would be no confusion. The wings were a little buttery and didn't have enough sauce but not terrible. The salad was another story. The chicken was bland, there wasn't much to the salad and the lettuce were so big that you couldn't possibly eat it without cutting it. The dressing wasn't good either. After a few bites of the salad I got fed up and threw it in the garbage. I hate wasting food but once you put the dressing on you can't save it and I didn't have any tomatoes or other veggies to throw on it to make it into a salad. O yeah, I didn't get a fork. Since when is it okay to give someone food without the proper utensils? The messed up at every turn and the worst part is this is the closest pizza place to my house. Never Again. PS I'm not editing this, not worth my time....don't order from here. There are good places in the neighborhood, just not this one.

  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by anonymous on 08/23/2012


    Best garlic knots on the Upper East Side. And I love the salamino. My go to lunch spot when I work from home.

  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/22/2012

    Best pizza


  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by Anonymous on 02/24/2012

    Not worth the trip

    To start, there is no lunch specials on Friday! Go figure? I ordered a pepperoni slice and a cheese slice both were there for a while as the oil had saturated the crust. Oh well glad there is more then a few pizza places here.

  • Pintailes Pizza

    Posted by anonymous on 01/21/2012

    Not recommended

    A friend recommended this place...needless to say, we are no longer friends. The pizza had NO taste...not enough sauce, not enough cheese, and honestly tasted like what I imagine cardboard to be like. And who knew that pepperoni could taste bad? The one and only good thing was that the girl who answered the phone was polite. Unfortunately, her politeness couldn't erase the bad taste left in my mouth.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.