Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Pick A Bagel
Posted by John on 11/17/2014
Bagels are not bad, some of the better ones in the area (does not say much). The issues is the service people simply do not care. We order from them a few times a week an orders are wrong 90% of the time. If you just want a bagel and will be happy with whatever you get then you won’t have issues with this place. If you want something specific, good luck.
Posted by Emma on 02/06/2012
2 hours and $22 later, my stale bagels arrived.
Posted by Dave on 09/26/2011
The guys behind the counter combine rudeness with not giving a sh*t. Even when I call ahead I end up having to wait 5 to 10 minutes to pick up my food. Prices are also a ripoff (but that's true everywhere in Battery Park).
Posted by George on 09/23/2011
Slow service, and they keep messing up orders. We ordered from them 2x this week, and they forgot some of the egg sandwiches both times.
Posted by Jennifer on 02/02/2009
Ordered a grilled cheese and a muffin. Took almost 50 minutes and two calls for the delivery man to get to my office. Pretty ridiculous. Worst of all, its the second time this happened.
Posted by Dave on 11/09/2008
My first, and last, experience with Pick a Bagel was completely unbelievable. We ordered a smoked white fish platter (9.99) 4 bagels and some juice. An hour later (and two phone calls later), the delivery finally made it to the apartment. Unfortunately, the order included a Smoked Fish Combo Platter (22.99). After calling back, the woman refused any solution besides sending the order back to be fixed. Assuming it would take another hour round trip, I had to cancel the whole thing and give up.
Posted by Jeanne on 08/28/2008
There are 4 things that I love to order from pick a bagel......egg & cheese on a bagel, their fruit salad, black & white cookies and tomato & mozzerella salad with asian dressing. They deliver in a second and they are very efficient in taking your order. It's a great place to grab a quick snack before heading into the movies next door.