Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Reviews from nymag.com
Posted by Dawn on 06/13/2009
Ok- The food is great. The staff seems genuinely friendly and attentive when you call for a delivery order. So the first time I call, I order a pizza and a few other things and they deliver the wrong pizza. I call them back, they were very nice about it, wanted to bring a new pizza out, told them it was ok.....so they offered a free replacement for the next time. The second time I call, I ordered a sandwich, the prosciutto, which on the menu says it has proscuitto, roasted peppers, basil and mozzarella, and of course my replacement pizza from the 1st time. They show up with my sandwich, and no pizza. I called them back immediately and they tell me they're sorry, they'll send one out. Which they very quickly did. The pizza was wonderful, the egglplant parm was great...the sandwich would have been wonderful had they not put a ton of balsamic vinegar on it. The menu never mentioned the balsamic and had it, I would have requested it be left off. So the gist of it...Great food, very nice staff, but they need to iron out the kinks...If you mess up the first time someone orders, maybe you'll get them to try a 2nd time....but if you mess up the 2nd time....even tho the food was good....I'm not really sure I would want to order again. I ordered out for the simplicity of it....no cooking, no hassle etc...
Posted by Audrey on 01/22/2009
They definitely have great staff and great food. Calling for delivery is so nice - they're always really nice, speak English, have a system where they remember your address, are always patient, and they even take credit cards over the phone. They can also try to make custom pasta dishes for you so you can choose your pasta, choose the type of sauce, choose the meat, etc etc which is very convenient. I like the whole wheat penne option.
Posted by Mike P on 10/21/2008
Don't be fooled by the Pizza Parlor motif. Peppino's is for serious pasta eaters and their eggplant parmigiana is among the best in Brooklyn. The thin crust brick oven pizza is very good and and their salads, served up with fresh baked flat bread straight from the wood fired oven, are a meal in themselves. The young and friendly wait staff are eager to please. The deserts are nothing special your basic restaurant supply fare but the espresso and cappuccino's are excellent. Peppino's is a true neighborhood gem.
Posted by Nikki[_]Bklyn on 03/15/2008
My boyfriend and I went in here last weekend and ordered their chicken parm hero and ceasar salad. Both were really great. The proportions were good as well. My bf & I shared both items and were full. The sandwich was a little pricey - about $9 I think, but it was worth it. I'll definitely go back. The place was very clean, and our waitress was a sweetheart. Highly recommended!