Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Pedro's Restaurant

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Mexican, Latin American
  • 73 Jay St, Brooklyn NY11201 40.702492 -73.986516
  • (At Front St)
  • click map to interact
  • (718) 569-5303
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 12 reviews)

Food 2.1 Value 2.1
Service 1.9 Atmosphere 2.0

Other Restaurant Info

(718) 569-5303
Place Order:
Order From Pedro's Restaurant for delivery & takeout
Delivery Take Out Cash Only
Lunch Special: Mon-Fri: 11am-4pm Happy Hour: Daily: 4pm-7pm
Dinner, Lunch
Delivery, Happy Hour, Live Music, Online Ordering, Outdoor Seating, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by Jimmy on 04/03/2014

    Avoid Like Plague!

    I have never bothered to write a review for a restaurant before, but for the first time I feel compelled to do so. Everything is a strange orange color. (the rice, the chicken). Looks like it was seasoned with Tang (powdered orange drink). I usually like mexican food, but this didn't even really resemble any kind of mexican food I've ever had before. Even if the food was amazing, it would still be overpriced. $16 for a chicken fajita. Not even Whole Foods would charge that much! There was a pool of oil at the bottom. Like a half inch deep. Not sure where that came from. Stay away.

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by anonymous on 08/12/2011

    Really just disappointing

    I could elaborate, but this place is all around unpleasant. Too bad it's DUMBO's only real Mexican offering.

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by Unhappy Diner on 04/27/2011

    Not what I expected

    I expected this place to have awesome food and margaritas instead we got only 1 choice of a premixed margarita that we had to go up and get ourselves along with our food because no one bothered to tell us that was how it worked. Instead the employees just looked at us and pretty much acted as no one was there. It was only 1 in the afternoon and now I see why this place was not at all packed! Very crappy service and treatment. The food was ok but as a whole I would no go back to this place. It sucks because it's a great location.

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by DKBK on 11/14/2010

    It's a mystery

    I work nearby and this place is always packed. But I just can't figure out why. Not only is it the worst Mexican I've ever had..but the food is just simply tasteless. The only thing I can assume, is that it's the loud music and cheap soft tacos that lures people in. Watch your head though..low ceiling. If you're in the mood for Mexican, this aint the place to go. But, if you don't really care about flavor and you just wanna hang out in the neighborhood..ya, okay.

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/18/2010

    Used to be great, terrible now...what happened?!?

    This place used to have good food at a great value. The quality of the food and the drinks at the bar both plummeted. (Worst margarita I have ever had) And at the same time, prices rose. What's going on? Did ownership change hands? I live in the neighborhood. Please bring the old Pedro's back and I will gladly eat and drink there again on a regular basis.

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/26/2010

    Not recommended

    The veggie burrito doesn't actually have any vegetables. It's just beans & rice, covered with sour cream & no guac! Beans are not a vegetable. So you pay $8 for a bowl of rice & beans in a wrap. To be fair there's chopped lettuce and salsa on the side.

  • Pedro's Restaurant

    Posted by totally anonymous on 09/21/2009

    Couldn't have been worse

    Despite the fact that my date and I sat down before two tables next to us, their orders were taken first. It was admittedly busy, and I'm usually very forgiving of waitstaff when a restaurant was packed. We ordered an appetizer (nachos), water, beer, and entrees. The two tables next to us received their drink orders quickly, before we were even given water. After twenty minutes had passed, we flagged down the waitress and asked for our water, beer, and nachos. Before receiving any of those things though, the tables next to us were served their dinner. We again asked the waitress for water and beer and nachos, and eventually did recieve them. While we were waiting, another two tables sat down behind us and had their orders taken. My date and I received our dinner at the same time as those two tables. And our dinner...my cheese tamale was completely inedible. It was nearly impossible to cut with silverwear, dry, cold, hard around the edges, and impossible to chew; I didn't get past the first bite. My date's beef burrito contained exactly that: beef. Even though he asked if there were beans in it and was told yes, there were black beans in it, the burrito was full of unseasoned beef, some white rice, and nothing else--no cheese, no totmatoes, no lettuce, no beans, nothing. Instead of ever asking if we needed more beer or more water, which yes, we did, the tables which entered after us and left before us were bussed although there was no one waiting to be seated. Getting our check wasn't any easier than getting our food. We felt purposefully ignored, and left both hungry and angry. This used to be a great place eat. The last few times I've been there have been disappointing. I doubt I'll go there again.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.