Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Reviews from nymag.com
Posted by SSlope340 Pie Skeptic on 08/04/2012
Ordered delivery from here last night for the sixth time. I was thrilled by the pie they brought, as I was the previous five times. Consistently excellent, delicious, and right. After nearly 12 years on NY, in various neighborhoods, this is now my clear favorite pizza delivery restaurant. As others have noted, the sauce is spicy and generous, the cheese is high-quality and not over-served. The veggies are fresh and perfectly cut. My pepperoni and green peppers pizza came with fresh (and I mean fresh) basil spread on it in just the right amount. Delicious pie with fast friendly deliver and reasonable prices. As long as I'm in this neighborhood, this is my pizza place.
Posted by Greenwood Heights Delivery on 06/24/2012
Just received my fourth or fifth order from Pauline & Sharon's. The pie arrived piping hot from a friendly delivery fella. Opening the box, the pizza was gorgeous. The taste matched. I've never been on-site at this restaurant, but the delivered pizza is fantastic! Excellent crust, great (spicy) sauce, not too heavy on the cheese. Exceptional service too.
Posted by Anonymous on 05/27/2012
Ordered from here for the first time tonight. What I received is one of the best pizzas I've had in Brooklyn. Thinner crust and more sauce than most places. Beautiful presentation including fresh basil leaves (on an order for simple pepperoni and green peppers). Surprisingly not too greasy too! I also appreciate the option of a 14" medium pie, often not available in NY. Delivery arrived quickly and piping hot. Excellent!
Posted by zound on 07/09/2011
Best pie I've had delivered in the slope so far. Great fairly spicy sauce, perfect crust. a couple chorizo tacos were also awesome, that might have to go on top my next pie....
Posted by Anonymous on 06/15/2011
I loved Peppe's back when it first opened, but sadly the quality slowly withered. Pauline and Sharon's an even better pie however. Their tomato sauce is nicely seasoned and the crust not too doughy, which is rare for this hood. Ask for the pie to be 'crispy'.
Posted by Anonymous on 04/16/2011
I used to get my pizza from another restaurant, but now I found a better place. P&S is so much better. They also have pasta on the menu. I highly recommend this place.
Posted by Anonymous on 02/05/2011
Not very doughy but oh so yummy.