
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by Dining Diva on 11/18/2009
I Am Done With Patsy's!!!
I have discovered the long and hard truth that Patsy's is just one of those eating establishments who think their cuisine is better than their patrons. Although I have experienced mediocrity in service over the past few years, I still continued to give them a considerable amount of my business. Tonight just took the cake and it was a long time coming. I decided to try something different aside from the pizza I usually order. The Fettucini Alfredo was below mediocre and they had the nerve to charge me the same price without the chicken as they would with chicken. When I brought this the the cashier's attention, she tried to justify it rather than remedy it. When I made her aware that they would lose a good patron over a few dollars, she seemed unfazed. So there it is. I will take my business to any other establishment in the area that is more appreciative of my busness. There are too many choices. I don't have to tolerate their lack or appreciation and customer service. You don't have to either. Take your appetite and busine$$ elsewhere!
Posted by Kay on 02/18/2009
Solid Food
This particular location is pretty good. The best Patsy's are the one on the UWS on Columbus and 74 and the one on 60th street and 3rd Ave. The pizza is delicious, so are the pastas and salads. This is the only restaurant where I find myself craving a salad. Their salads are super fresh and hearty. Their white pizza is mouth watering (try it with garlic as a topping, it's worth the extra $2).
Posted by Christmas eve special on 12/26/2008
Great Service....NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I have been to many of the Patsy's restaurants around this city, but this one is truly an experience. According to the manager, "You can't tell me what to put in my food." This was a response to his staff being unable to handle making the salad without anchovies, olives, and with the dressing on the side. I am sure you are all thinking, what "rocket science" this actually must entail. Apparently Patsy's is too "high-scale" to deviate from the extravigant menu. The manager was extremely rude and must believe that they are considered an elite dining facility.
Posted by Loppo on 11/21/2008
Great Place
This is one of our go-to places in the neighborhood. Perfect for a weekend lunch or dinner any night. The pizza is so good - thin and crispy crust and excellent ingredients. Also, the salads and pasta dishes are also great. Everyone we've taken here has loved this place - kids and grown-ups alike. The only thing I don't like is that when it's crowded it can be quite loud.
Posted by Anonymous on 07/23/2008
Yummy
The pizza here was great. I ordered the pie and had roasted peppers on top. It was immensely sweet tasting. I really enjoyed it as did my present company. No this is definately not the place to go if you are famished by any means or are searching for a proliferous amount of topping. This is the ideal pizzeria for the minimalist. I had a craving for great thin-crust pizza. This completely satisfied me and my craving. Not for abundance. Can't express this more . Definitely worth the price $33 for fried calamari and a pie with roasted peppers on top for 2 people in NYC thats pretty great.
Posted by Anti-Salad on 02/19/2008
Salad’s vs. Fat Wrapped in Fats
I am your typical artery clogging grease ball loving steak bone sucking chicken skin crunching eater, however I must applaud the salads at patsy. A group of co-workers and I went for lunch and we are a fairly equal mix of “Salad’s” vs. “Fat Wrapped in Fat’s”. So it was pleasantly surprising that we all raved more about the salads then the pizzas (which were good). It’s not too often that my mind will linger on and on about an amazing salad, but I must admit for a girl like me who loves fat wrapped in fat kind of foods…the salads are heavy on my mind. Kudos to Patsy for trying to lure me to the other team. Go Salads! P.S. I found the quality of the ingredient to be excellent across the board. Slight pricey but worth it!
Posted by Murray Hill Resident on 11/09/2007
Way overpriced, don't go here
This place is way overpriced. It definitely looks nice from the outside but they charge $2.50 for each topping (only exceptions being garlic, which is $1, and prosciutto which is $3.50) regardless of whether it is on half or all of the pie. That would be fine, if they actually put a decent amount of toppings on but they barely put any on. They are also really cheap with cheese leaving you with, essentially, a cheaply made piece of matzah pizza. The pizza place one block south is far better though more proletarian in atmosphere. Don't be a patsy to the pizza crime going on at Patsy's