Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown West >
Posted by Anonymous on 08/28/2014
This place got rave reviews in the past but now far from those acclaims. When we arrived, was shocked to see the place so empty during the after work and pre theater hours. We ordered our food and got it promptly. The Shepard pie was average and crabcakes were tiny and warm and soggy, probably premade and not to order. For such an empty restaurant, more servers than patrons, the wait staff never checked again after our orders or refilled our water. The most outrageous act was packing our food to go without even closing the container and throwing it inside a plastic bag, causing food to spill out. Really disappointed in this place!
Posted by Amia on 06/30/2011
I love this place. I have to go everytime I am in Times Square. As a matter of fact I will be there tomorrow. The food is great, the drinks are never watered down and the atmosphere is fun and inviting. If you havent been you must go.
Posted by Brenda on 04/26/2011
We went to this place twice while in NYC and loved it both times. I had the special: steak salad, it was fantastic. The atmosphere is great and the drinks are some of the cheapest you will find in times square.
Posted by dc on 11/26/2010
Great place! If I was a NewYorker I would be a regular? Fish&Chips, hash (eggs a bit overdone and bangers&mash were yummy! (Shepard's pie almost ok.) Went Thanksgiving day for lunch...was still hoping the stew (thurs special) was still on but the had a nice turkey/brisket thing going on... Would not have found it if not for MP!!! (thanks all!) Would definitely go again!
Posted by O'No!! on 01/31/2010
When you come to Manhattan and have literally hundreds of restaurants to chose from, I don't see any reason to choose this one. The bread was stale. My entree was bland. The service was ok and the meals were on our table immediately. The price was low, especially considering the location. But in the end you have to serve good food, and I was really disappointed with the tasteless, unattractive meal I was served and won't be back. One thing I must mention was I did receive a tastey, perfectly poured Guinness.
Posted by Sorocha on 10/16/2008
Visited this bar/restaurant last weekend with my family. Must say the service was outstanding but the food was very disappointing... Although the restaurant wasn't busy the entrees were cold...... I had the chicken dish with mashed potato........Cold mashed potato I might add...Seemed to have sat in the kitchen a little too long. May go back for drinks again but will definately eat elsewhere.
Posted by Pam, Wendy, Merry & Debbie on 10/03/2008
We went on a late Saturday afternoon and the restaurant was only half full. The food was excellent with some unusual dishes that we tried and loved. O'Lunney's is moderately priced and you get a lot of food for the money. Nobody could finish their food. Try the squash soup if it is available, it 's excellent. Service was great and it isn't on the tourist list, which makes it a relaxing and enjoyable place to eat.