Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Irish, Bar Food, Pizza, Fish & Chips
  • 160 W 54th St, New York NY10019 40.763269 -73.98108
  • (At 7th Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 471-4860
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 18 reviews)

Food 4.2 Value 4.2
Service 4.3 Atmosphere 4.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 471-4860
(212) 471-4863
Delivery Takeout Private Parties Major Credit Cards
Kitchen Mon-Fri: 8am-11pm Sat-Sun: 8am-11pm Bar and Bar Menu Sun-Tues: 11pm-1am Fri-Sat: 11pm-2am
Breakfast, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Brunch, Delivery, Good for Groups, Happy Hour, Kid Friendly, Late Night, Pre/Post Theater, Private Parties, Take Out

User Reviews

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by UES on 05/05/2008

    Not a Pub

    This place is lit like a diner and is quite pricey. There is zero pub atmosphere and the food is not good. Chicken fingers were dry and flavorless, wings were coated in a sweet bbq sauce like Kraft, and the potato skins were mealy. The burger was small and unremarkable. Will not be back.

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by David Ft. Lauderdale on 12/30/2007


    Everytime I visit the Theatre District, I make it a point to eat at Oldcastle. The ambience is far from pretentious -- it is true to form real Irish pub with friendly faces and excellent home cooked cuisine. Highest recommendation.

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by Lee from King's Lynn, England on 06/19/2007

    great little place

    We stumbled upon this place one saturday night. And glad we did. It actually felt more English than Irish. Premiership football and a pint of Tetleys. Lovely-jubbly. Very friendly waitress, tasty bar food. Definately be back..

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by Anonymous on 03/03/2007

    Good Food, Poor Service

    Stopped in early on a snowy January evening, food was good, not remarkable but fine. The waitress we started with was great, but she was sent upstairs shortly after taking our order and our "replacement" was terrible. She could barely make eye contact with us and literally threw the food on the table. After the meal we had to ask for coffee and then chase her down for a refill. The restaurant was not packed, and if it was I could certainly understand her being busy - but not so busy she couldn't speak. I doubt we will go back as the same quality of food is available elsewhere and it won't be hard to find better service. I understand that all restaurants have an off night, but I don't want to spend $70+ for the waitress's bad day.

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by Elaine and Mike on 07/14/2006

    Morning and Evening

    We ate hereon numerous occasions both at breakfast and evening.It was so convenient as we were staying at thr Rhiga Royal across the road.Breakfast were varied and fulfilling the evening meals were well cooked and presented really well,service was always friendly, couteous and even being Christmas time never had to wait too long for a table.Also being from over the pond the guiness was most welcome

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by City Regular on 01/01/2006

    So, so

    While in the city to see a show stopped in on recommendations from this site. Found it to be so, so. Dined upstairs, very busy. Had a fairly long wait for service, order and check. Food was typical bar fare. Let down when chicken in ranch wrap was fried and overpowered with bacon. Not thrilled by the experience.

  • Oldcastle Pub & Restaurant

    Posted by Ann on 11/02/2005

    Great Find

    We really enjoyed our time there. We were having dinner before boarding a bus back to CT. The waitresses were great and the food was delicious. We highly recommend it and plan to return there on our next trip.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.