Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:
Now Serving: 15630 Menus for New York City Restaurants
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
| Food |  |
Value |  |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | |
Atmosphere |  |
Posted by Chris N on 01/03/2013
Second Class Citizen!
Food was phenomenal, lets start there. However, I've never been treated quite as much like a second class citizen in my life. The staff was largely rude and impatient. On numerous occasions the waiter stopped halfway through addressing our table to go wait on another table where he clearly assumed there would be a larger tip. I wouldn't waste my time at the Old Homestead NYC again. There are too many phenomenal steakhouses in NYC to be frustrated by such an experience. Unless you are a regular at this restaurant, go to Peter Luger's, Del Monico's, etc. Much, much better comprehensive dining experience.
Posted by Brucenyc on 12/22/2012
Fantastic
Went there last week with a few friends to celebrate a couple of birthdays. The meal was fantastic from the appetizers to the dessert. A better steakhouse cannot be found.
Posted by victor lalo on 07/02/2011
I am a reguler @ old homestead
I been comming to the old Homestead steak house for about five years now and its something that I crave for every now and then. What prompted me to write a review was all the really wrong reviews about this steak house. If you believe the negative reviews your missing out on good foood and good service. The only cut I order is the gothem rib-eye steak cooked to medium and I crave it every now and then. I have eaten the coby burger there but its not good there. I have eaten Koby meet and you could never say a bad thing about koby beef, its like amazing. I love Old homestead, so recommend it.
Posted by Anonymous on 05/09/2011
Going here everyday now!
First time today, I really wanted a good steak. It was amazing sat outside in the afternoon sun. Amazing food and service.
Posted by EP on 05/03/2011
Not recommended
Just had bachelor party dinner here on Saturday night with a 9:30 pm reservation and the staff made my party of 15 wait around until finally seating us at 11:30 pm! Horrible experience. Steaks are good but there are many, many other better steak houses in the city. The staff was horrible, from the 2 hosts to the waiters. Avoid this overpriced landmark.
Posted by SD on 05/02/2011
Don't go here for a group reservation
We had reservations for a party of 12. We ended up waiting nearly 2 hours. Would have left, but the staff kept on saying 15 minutes. Very unprofessional. Otherwise, food was good, but definitely never go here for a big group event.
Posted by Chic in the City on 04/11/2011
Avoid
My husband and I are big NYC diners and entertain often. We went here Saturday to celebrate our 1st Wedding Anniversary and had the worst dining experience. We waited 20 minutes for menus, the service was horrible and the food was just ok. Very different from how it used to be. Ambience was non-existant (it reminded me of Friday's) and had a lot of non descript tourists. This place is no longer a NY staple, it was amateur hour. The manager tried to fix things but a round of drinks wasn't going to help.