Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Murray Hill / Gramercy >
American (Traditional) >
Posted by Midtown Diner on 01/08/2015
This was a Midtown Gem. Sad to say it was closed by the Marshall just before Christmas 2014.
Posted by Anonymous on 11/17/2011
After looking for a "decent" place to have a late lunch and a drink, the restaurant was quite cozy, a little "crowded" for us (8 people), but that's to be expected. A "round" of "shots", yes 1 round, and 1 appetizer for each, our bill was freaking over $200.00! They charged us $10.00 per shot! Need I say more! I know it's NY, but give me a freaking break! I would NEVER go back, there's too many nicer, more reasonable places to eat/drink!
Posted by Mpc on 10/16/2011
For a basic bar meal with good service and lively atmosphere you will not be disappointed
Posted by Anonymous on 12/29/2010
Very good food, staff was excellent. Bartender even gave us a buyback, rarely find buybacks in midtown. Prices were average. Ill recommend this place anytime.
Posted by anonymous on 11/08/2010
The food here is excellent. Generous portions, excellent value and presentation, and the service.....fantastic. The bartender was charming and attentive and brought such life to the bar. She alone is worth coming back to see. Great.
Posted by Mary Collins on 06/16/2010
I was on a trip to New York with my partner and visited O' Caseys for lunch and a quick drink. We were making the most of our day exploring 5th Ave and came across the bar and being Irish my partner couldnt wait for a good pint. He had a pint of the black stuff which was in his words "one of the best I have ever had out of Ireland". I stuck to a mineral water and we both had burger and fries for our meal. The food was delicious, just what we needed to boost us for the rest of the afternoon exploring NCY. The staff were all lovely and very friendly and service was prompt. There was a lovely atmosphere and as we were leaving it was getting busier and busier with people setteling down to their meals. I will definately be returning if I am lucky enough to get back to NY.
Posted by anonymous on 02/11/2009
atmosphere was a little nicer than your typical irish pub. do not get the onion soup...a huge disappointment. burgers are just ok. and they are very skimpy on the fries. i had maybe 8-10 fries on my plate. the service is very slow. took about 30-40 minutes for our burgers to come out.