Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Notaro Ristorante

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Italian
  • 635 2nd Ave, New York NY10016 40.745322 -73.975811
  • (Btwn 34th & 35th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 686-3400
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 57 reviews)

Food 4.2 Value 4.2
Service 4.3 Atmosphere 4.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 686-3400
(212) 686-0474
Place Order:
Order From Notaro Ristorante for delivery & takeout
Catering Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Sun-Thu: 12pm-11pm Fri-Sat: 12pm-11:30pm
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Delivery, Good for Groups, Lunch Special, Online Ordering, Online Reservations, Pre/Post Theater, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Jane Smith on 03/12/2008

    Nice Romantic atmosphere/fireplace

    The atmosphere was amazing. the staff was impeccable and the surroundings were very romantic and relaxing (fireplace) incredible food, it's very reasonable prices for this quality food....Definitely I recommend this lovely restaurant

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Good Food on 03/05/2008

    Great Little Italian Place

    I have to disagree with the last two posts. I had a wonderful experience at Notaro. Great food, an absolutely wonderful server and a really nice atmosphere.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by mereditor on 02/23/2008

    Not so good

    After waiting a full 20 minutes to get menus, I had a feeling this place was going to be a disappointment, and it was. There weren't that many other people in there, so there was no reason for the delay for getting our menus. We had to ask for them twice. Our appetizer, Mozzarella in Carrozza was actually delicious, but our cokes tasted funny, like they had expired cherry flavoring in them. My fettucine alfredo was 100% tasteless. I had to cover it in cheese, salt and pepper for me to know I was eating anything at all. It comes with shrimp and I asked for it without shrimp. The waiter asked me if I wanted chicken instead and I told him, "No, just plain." The fettucine arrived covered in chicken. The waiter realized the mistake and offered us a free dessert which was a nice touch. We turned it down because we were stuffed from cold bread and mediocre food. But he brought out the dessert anyway. It was tasty, but we didn't enjoy it as much as we could have because we weren't hungry and he stood over us talking to us while we ate it. He seemed like a nice guy, but it was a little awkward that he kept talking. I wouldn't go back here or recommend this place to anyone.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by anonymous on 12/15/2007


    I don't mean to be a downer, especially since this place has pretty good reviews from others, however I ordered dinner from Notaro tonight and was really disappointed. I had the gnocci which was like starchy balls of potato...not what gnocci is supposed to be like. The sauce was okay, but didn't have a lot of flavor. I had a cannoli for dessert and it was stale. The filling was like melted ice cream and it was a little chunky. I won't be eating there again.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Anonymous on 10/19/2007


    Everything from the décor to the service makes Notaro’s my absolute favorite Italian restaurant. I take everyone I love. The Notaro experience begins with a warm greeting by staff at the door. I personally love to sit at the back area next to the fireplace (this can very romantic when with a significant other, and is very cozy with family and friends). It's hard to choose my entree, but one of my favorite dishes is the Shrimp Scampi followed closely by Bocconcino de Pollo. And to satisfy my sweet tooth, I have the tiramisu. Exquisite! Notaro has unbeatable prix lunch and dinner menus (with a new early dinner menu from 4-6:30) that are comprised of a great assortment of selections. Everyone makes a genuine effort to make your experience satisfying. The truth is that Notaro has left a lasting impression, because no other restaurant compares with the quality of food and service that Notaro offers. I definatley recommend Notaro’s to everyone. Enjoy!

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by anonimous on 09/19/2007

    it could be much better

    I used to eat great food at this place some how the taste and flavor is not the same perhaps they change the Chef however I hope they get back the great same taste and cuality of the food.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by me on 08/20/2007


    Went last weekend with a group of 6. We all ordered different entrees (shellfish, chicken, veal, fish). The food took a little while (since they make everything to order) but it came out HOT and delicious, and huge portions. I can't wait to go back! The homemade pasta was such a treat, the bread was fantastic, and the service was anything but rushed. Fantastic find.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.