Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Notaro Ristorante

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Italian
  • 635 2nd Ave, New York NY10016 40.745322 -73.975811
  • (Btwn 34th & 35th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 686-3400
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 57 reviews)

Food 4.2 Value 4.2
Service 4.3 Atmosphere 4.1

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 686-3400
(212) 686-0474
Place Order:
Order From Notaro Ristorante for delivery & takeout
Catering Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Sun-Thu: 12pm-11pm Fri-Sat: 12pm-11:30pm
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Catering, Delivery, Good for Groups, Lunch Special, Online Ordering, Online Reservations, Pre/Post Theater, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Sandi149 on 03/25/2012

    Really lovely restaurant

    My husband and I met friends last night at Notaro. I decided to go to this establishment based on the reviews on here. We really loved it. The food was excellent as was the service. The only thing that I would complain about is that they got our main courses mixed up but it was no big deal as we swapped it with our friends and everything was fine. In lieu of that, we received complimentary after dinner cordials. The price of the food is moderate but beware that if you drink a lot, the bill will definitely add up. The atmosphere is really lovely....very dark and romantic. Highly recommended and I will return again.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Anonymous on 09/08/2011

    Secret gem!

    This restaurant provides impeccable service and the food was so delicious it melted in your mouth. The prix fixe dinner menu gives this place the two thumbs up. Can't wait to dine here again!

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Gabriel on 08/24/2011

    Best kept secret!

    From the first time I entered Notaro, I knew it was going to be a wonderful experience. Sometimes you just know. And I was not disappointed. The food is exceptional, the service impeccable, and the atmosphere unparalelled. The Antipasto, Carpaccio and thier entrees cannot be beat. The Mushroom Farfalle was absolutley amazing!

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by barky on 08/08/2011

    Price fixe is hard to beat

    The other reviews are largely accurate. My wife and I had the prix fixe dinner there recently and found Notaro to be a very pleasant experience. For the first course I ordered the eggplant rollatine, which resembled manicotti with riccota and mozzarella. It was tasty as any cheese filled dish would be but the portion was small. My wife had the salad which was excellent with a very pleasing dressing. For the main course I had the basa fish fillet which was excellent in every way; she had the chicken scarpariello, which was good but the meat could have been more tender. Both dishes came with linguini in the same sauce as the dish itself. The pasta was perfect and the sauce also was excellent; the piccante sauce if not well done can often ruin dishes such as these, but not here. For dessert we had chocolate cake (nothing exceptional) and tiramisu. The tiramisu was the better choice as it was essentially chocolate cake with a flavorful topping. My only criticisms are that there were no vegetables present in any of the dishes (even the eggplant was scant). It is summer, so there is no reason for their exclusion. The grissini were fine but the bread was stale, which not unusual for restaurants, but a minor issue. Unfortunate for the bread itself was of high quality. Waiting time for the food prep was substantial, but that did not seem to be the fault of the waitstaff which is very attentive. The decor is pleasant enough, not ostentatious. The portions are ample, not huge, but you won't leave hungry either. The prix fixe is a good deal and is available until closing, which is not common and a welcome treat for those who dine late. I wouldn't say it is the best Italian food I've ever had but it is far above average and really quite good.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by happy! on 12/29/2009

    great all around

    I ate here with my parents from DC, because my dad loves using cupons and found a cupon for this place. i was totally skeptical but was we were all so suprised. we litterally did not leave ONE thing left on our plates. Pa got the filet minon special, mom got sea-bass, sister got mushroom ravioli special, i got gnocci.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by Anonymous on 12/23/2009


    Excellent food for a reasonable price. Waiters are very attentive and work hard for their tip. Loved the chocolate cake. Delicious and wonderful. Will definitely come back.

  • Notaro Ristorante

    Posted by anonymous on 12/22/2009

    Beware of private parties

    We had a reservation and were seated in the back of the restaurant, where we later noticed that there were several large tables of people making up a private party. There is no separate room or partition to accomodate a private party. The group became extremely loud and because of their size, the service to other tables became extremely slow. Before paying the check, we complained to the manager that we should have been informed about a private party in the dining room before being seated. There were no adjustments made to our bill and we were quite annoyed when we left. The food is rather pricey for Italian and nothing special for NYC.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.