Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Michelle on 2013-08-09
I love this pizza and that it always seems fresh out of the oven. I especially like the grandma slice topped with crisp arugula and freshly grated parmesan cheese. The crust is crispy. I usually order their eggplant parmesan but am now addicted to Nonn
Posted by Annie Birdseed on 2012-04-23
Feta cheeze and spinach pie on the menu is always a dead giveaway and soggy pizza crust another. The sauce is VERY good though and their spaghetti was perfect. Meatballs need some work. Haven't had the sausage but maybe that's better. All in all, I
Posted by anonymous on 2011-11-09
Walked by and stopped in for a couple slices one day, and they were top notch. Great, fresh, quality ingredients. I decided to give their lasagna a shot and I have to say, I swear they stole the recipe from my grandmother. The sauce is flavorful, beef is
Posted by Rockin'Robel on 2011-10-20
Square Margherita pie is a must! Grandma's recipe they call it. Best value is the side order of Meat Balls - comes with a small loaf of bread smothered in their homemade sauce (best in the whole area) for about $6. But add the fresh Mozzarella for another
Posted by Chuck on 2011-10-14
I've had Lombardi's. I've had Patsy's. Don't get me wrong, they're really good. But Nonna's is the best pizza in New York hands down! Grandma slices at their best! They have the highest quality ingredients, and make their own fresh mozzarella in the back.
Posted by new York City Girl on 2011-09-23
I alway would run by on my way to the east river. I only rated the atmosphere as a 3.0 because of no other reason than it not being a date kind of spot.
However, the pizza is SO good. I usually get the square margarida.
I am surprised I enjoy it so much
Posted by Zoe on 2011-07-25
Really really good (.;
Posted by anonymous on 2011-06-13
love this pizza - tried a bunch of different ones and liked them all. we order from here all the time though they changed the entire menu fairly recently and some items haven't kept up (the penne a la vodka was not the best the last time we ordered but u