Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

New York Pizza Suprema

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Pizza
  • 413 8th Ave, New York NY10001 40.750205 -73.995321
  • (At 31st St)
  • click map to interact
  • (917) 791-5111
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 21 reviews)

Food 4.4 Value 4.2
Service 3.9 Atmosphere 3.5

Other Restaurant Info

(917) 791-5111
Place Order:
Order From New York Pizza Suprema for delivery & takeout
Delivery Take-Out Major Credit Cards
Daily: 10:30am-12am
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Lunch, Online Ordering, Take Out
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by FoodDUDE on 11/04/2013

    Slice Harvester Was Right!

    I had been meaning to try this place after reading an article in the Wall Street Journal about a guy who went to every pizza place in Manhattan and rated this one the best. Well, he was spot on!!! The crust was so crunchy and flavorful, the sauce was like none other in my life and the cheese was nice and sharp. I could of had three slices but my wife wouldn't let me. Go check this place out and you will be amazed!

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by Kent - From Chelsea on 03/02/2012

    Best Pizza in NY

    So i'm a native New Yorker. I've had pizza all over NYC all my life. 10 years ago I moved to Chelsea. This Pizza shop is a few blocks from where I live. The first time I had the pizza I was like "wow this is the best pizza ever"... I thought it was one of those rare things that happens and that it was not going to be as good the next time... well that was 10 years ago... I don't know what magic trick they do but this is really the best pizza in NYC and I would say anywhere. When people come from other states and ask me for the best pizza... I send them all there. And they all say the same thing. I thought that maybe it was just me... but it seems that everyone agrees with me on it. I hope they continue this pizza forever. One of the best things from me moving to Chelsea has been to find this amazing pizza. Hope this review gets more people to taste this pizza.... thanks KHN

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by Anonymous on 06/03/2011

    Used to be the best Not anymore

    We used to get pizza delivered weekly from here and it was amazing. Not anymore. What a shame. Must be new management.

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/19/2009

    Best pizza in nyc

    I eat here almost everyday for lunch. I've had a lot of pizza in my day, this one has a really authentic, unique taste to it that doesn't feel greasy and heavy after you eat it...I've recommended it to friends and they go all the time! Service is incredible; even at lunch's busiest hours, the workers by the oven are fast and efficient. A must have!!

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by nycfoodiechick on 08/11/2009


    It saddens me to think that for my entire life I didn't know what pizza was simply because I hadn't had this pizza until a week ago. My new boyfriend who happens to live around the corner from this place has been eating pizza here since he was a kid and is on a first name basis with the owner Joe whose father owned it for over 40 yrs. These people know how to make pizza. I like the fresh mozzarella and basil. The crust is thin and slightly charred, the sauce is tangy and slightly sweet and the cheese is just so fresh (they make their own). I never liked pizza until I had this pizza. You guys have a new customer and I'm letting all my friends know.

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by Joker on 07/05/2009

    What happened?

    What happened? This place used to have the greatest pizza! But it definitely took a turn for the worst. The pizza is not what it used to be. I like a well done pizza but more often than not, it's burnt. Where's the cheese? They seemed to have cut back on the cheese bigtime. Then the sauce! The sauce is what really made this pizza great. It lost its nice sweetness and is actually sour at times now and a little too much of it. I hope they didn't change the recipe, but it looks like it. Maybe it's new management, since it has been remodeled lately. This is just recent because i have been eatin this pizza for years and would give it a 5 if it were the old pizza. So dissappointing!

  • New York Pizza Suprema

    Posted by Fred on 06/12/2009

    Going Against The Grain: Didn't Like It

    This pizza place and Italian restaurant is located right near Penn Station in New York. They have been in business for over 40 years. . Now I have to admit that I am going “against the grain” if you will Swimming upstream. Going backwards up the stairs. Why? Because other people who have reviewed this place gave it high marks. I just cannot do that. So why did I not like this place? First of all, very rushed service. Instead of “What would you like?” or “Can I help you?” They simply YELL “NEXT!” Like fast-food pizza. Yes they serve a lot of people this way, but with poor attitude. The atmosphere is very mediocre, but then again, I can forgive that because it is just a pizza joint. They have seating for about 30 people. There is really no ambiance or table service if you were to order a meal. But I can let that go too. What I cannot let go is the quality. The slice that I got was overcooked o n the bottom, had very little cheese, and the sauce was runny. It just goes to figure I was wearing a white shirt so you do the math. The slice had very little flavor, the sauce was nothing to write home about, and overall it was just OK at best. It was something to fill an empty stomach, that’s the best way to describe it. Oh and the price? $3.00 for a slice of pepperoni. Add in the root bear I had and it came to $4.50. Too much money for the quality of food.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.