Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

New York Burger Co. (CLOSED)

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Burgers, Hot Dogs
  • 303 Park Ave S, NEW YORK NY10010 40.740247 -73.985768
  • (Btwn 23rd & 24th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 254-2727
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 59 reviews)

Food 3.3 Value 2.7
Service 3.3 Atmosphere 2.8

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 254-2727
(212) 254-2448
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Mon-Fri: 11am-10:30pm Sat-Sun: 11am-10pm
Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery, Good for Groups, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible
Min Delivery:
Delivery Area:
9th to 36th St FDR Dr to Fifth Ave

User Reviews

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by Gramercy Gal on 08/01/2009

    Great Local Burger-centric Joint!

    I've been ordering Burgers and Turkey Burgers from New York Burger Co. for the last year or so. In my opinion is this a VERY solid option all around. Its a burger that you are going to get a pricey steak restaurant, but its certainly a cut above anything you would get at your local diner. The meat is always delicious and juicy prepared just as I have asked. The bread is always a fresh treat and welcome addition, an not a throw away holder. The lettuce and tomato are always very nice and fresh as well. I love adding avocado and hot peppers to my burger! Along with the burgers being a delight, the side dishes get a big thumbs up as well, the endless shoe string onion rings are my favorite. New York Burger Co. also serves up a wide array of flavored mayos to choose from to top your burger with. I order delivery from this place, the staff is always very lovely on phone, my ordered is delivered quickly, and everything is always as it should be (nothing is spilled or a mess.) I am a big fan and highly recommend New York Burger Co. as an above average Burger option in the Gramercy/Flatiron area.

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by TD-2243 on 06/04/2009

    A good burger, but not top 10

    My friends and I try to visit a new burger joint every couple of weeks. Last night we came to New York Burger Company. My meal came to about $18.50 for a bacon cheeseburger, onion rings and a shake. That's about on par for burger places in NYC that aren't a restaurant per se. This is more of a high quality fast food joint. For the money it costs, I felt the portions were just okay. The burger wasn't big (Jackson Hole), but wasn't small either (Shake Shack). As far as the taste, it has a good taste to it and it was properly cooked. I wish it had come with more onion rings because they were great. The malt I ordered was good too, but not spectacular at $4.50. There are better bangs for the buck if you want a quick burger, but this is pretty good. The best and tastiest burgers for the money that I've had in this city are 5 Napkin Burger, Joy Burger, Ted's Montana Grill, Rare, and Jackson Hole. Those seem to impress every time and you get your money's worth at each of those places. The best fast food type burger is Good Burger, which is the vibe NY Burger Co. is trying to go for. Just not quite as good.

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by Anonymous on 07/07/2008

    condiment heaven

    The burgers are juicy and great. Wonderful place if you love condiments. I recommend the ketchup with chili peppers.

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by Anonymous on 05/29/2008

    Great burger, great salads

    The burger is pretty good, perfect and really tasty. The salads are pretty good as well even though they're huge. Not so sure about the multigrain bun or brioche bread that come with the salads, I took one bite and had to throw it out. This is a place I keep coming back again and again for the burgers and salads though. Mini burgers are ok, not as juicy and sumptuous as the big ones. And the hot dogs aren't anything special.

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by rella on 03/24/2008

    not good

    Just ordered delivery for the 1st time because I wanted to try something more 'upscale' than the local diner. We both got turkey burgers. Of course they were soggy by the time they arrived, but you kind of expect that to a certain degree. My first bite there was a loud 'crunch' - I thought I broke a tooth. Tried again, the burger was hard as a rock, couldn't manage a 3rd bite, I was so appaled with the texture and flavor. Then my husband took a bite and another loud 'crunch'! I don't know what kind of turkey meat they are using - we thought we bit into a piece of beak or something.

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by Midtown Artist on 03/02/2008

    Pricey but Tasty

    I tried this place for the first time unexpectedly when meeting my girlfriend after a meeting and we couldn't believe how tasty (in a guilty way) the burgers and sweet potato fries were. I've been back twice since and it's always fairly good - and greasy - but I'm hoping that the prices will hold steady and the quality of service will pick up a bit. Most servers have attitude and don't speak very clearly. It is also a bit expensive for a burger and fries, but I don't mind it too much. A true guilty pleasure.

  • New York Burger Co.

    Posted by Anonymous on 02/03/2008

    good burger

    I ordered a burger and onions rings through delivery today. I really enjoyed the burger and thought the burger sauce that came with it was very good. The onion rings were okay, i like them more crispy, these we the flakey type.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.