Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Neelys (CLOSED)

  • $$$
  • 1125 1st Ave, New York 10065 40.761446 -73.960836
  • (Btwn 61st & 62nd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (917) 717-5954
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 54 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 2_5 Value 2
Service 3 Atmosphere 3

Other Restaurant Info

(917) 717-5954
Visa, MC, AmEx, Disc
Mon-Fri: 4pm-11pm Sat: 11am-1am Sun: 11am-11pm
Min Delivery:

User Reviews

  • Neelys

    Posted by marzi on 2013-12-02

    Very Satisfying

    A very friendly waiter, fast service and everything was delicious. We all ordered baby back ribs and they were perfect. Sides were all good. Fantastic corn bread. Have had other items before like the fried green tomatoes which are great and brisket.

  • Neelys

    Posted by DMB on 2013-05-29

    Not good.

    First, this in no way reflects the service. Our waitress was awesome, bus boys were attentive etc. I'm a HUGE fan of the Neelys because of the Food Network, so my mom bought me $100 in gift certificates for my bday. Unfortunately, the food was severel

  • Neelys

    Posted by Eric on 2013-05-03

    Simply No Good!

    Bottom line: the food isn't good! Cornbread is hard as a rock served with frozen butter, pulled pork is dry, mac and cheese is subpar, brisket is underseasoned. The menu isn't very exciting, the atmosphere isn't anything to write home about, service was

  • Neelys

    Posted by Doretha Williams on 2013-03-25


    I went to Neely for my nephew's wedding. It was a party of 20 people and no one had any complaints. The food and service was excellent. I would definitely go again.

  • Neelys

    Posted by Peggy on 2012-10-04

    Huge Letdown

    What a let down! The portions are small, the sauce tastes like it is full of artificial stuff, and the food is anything but fresh!

  • Neelys

    Posted by Anonymous on 2012-09-24

    From Memphis...Loved Neelys

    If you don't know about BBQ then please don't say this restaurant is poor. The cornbread is great. The fried pickles are great. The Memphis style ribs (must get them "dry" so they are authentic) are true Memphis ribs. The Kansas city style ribs are amazin

  • Neelys

    Posted by Joseph C on 2012-08-28


    Ist time at Neely's. Took my wife and we were very happy with everything. Was seated right away. And our host Brenda was excellent. We had the 3 little pigs (Pulled Pork) and was not disappointed. Out of this world. Corn Bread was great. Had the Memphis B

  • Neelys

    Posted by gold on 2012-08-06

    sad for the neely's

    We were looking forward to a meal there as we hadn't been in about a year. Well we had to send the fried green tomatoes back as they were soggy and oily. Our very sweet waitress was very apologetic and brought us another order only to have the same experi

© 2018 Grubhub, Inc. All rights reserved.