Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

My Most Favorite Food

  • $$$$
    RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • American (New), Bakeries, Kosher, Desserts
  • 247 W 72nd St, New York NY10023 40.779618 -73.983276
  • (Btwn West End & Amsterdam Ave)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 580-5130
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 43 reviews)

Food 3.2 Value 2.5
Service 2.9 Atmosphere 2.9

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 580-5130
(212) 580-5135
Place Order:
Order From My Most Favorite Food for delivery & takeout
Visa, MC, AmEx, DC General Hours Mon-Tue: 8:30am-10pm Wed-Thu: 8:30am-11pm Fri: 8:30am-3pm Sat: 2 hours after sundown-1 am Sun: 9:30am-10pm
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Brunch
Group Dining, Open Late, Outdoor Dining, Pre/Post Theater, Delivery, Online Ordering, Wheelchair Friendly, Accepts Credit Cards, Take Out, Catering

User Reviews

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by Anonymous on 12/19/2007

    Food is Excellent, Delivery is Poor

    At the request of my boss, I ordered lunch for the whole office. I asked the girl on the phone to have it here for noon (this was at 11:30), she said she'd rush it. When the food wasn't here by 12:20, I called and checked and was told it was on its way. When it wasn't here by 1:00, I called and spoke with the manager who assured me it was on its way despite my displeasure from the delay. It got here shortly after that, but having to wait an hour and a half for lunch is inexcusable. The food was delicious, the portions were great, but I wouldn't recommend ordering it for delivery!

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by Anonymous on 08/12/2007

    Solid Meal

    We just so happened to walk down 45th street and we fell upon this lovely restaurant with terrific vintage posters on the wall. Staff was attentive and knowlegeable. Food was excellent and to our surprise it was "kosher". The fish was superb and cooked perfectly and the desserts were out of this world. We eat out non-kosher and this was some of the best fish I have ever eaten. We will definately return to this restaurant.

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by LocalDiner on 02/12/2007

    Overpriced and Little Value

    I stopped by for a workday lunch after 2 PM, after the lunch rush. The place was empty of diners but full of staff. I waited over 25 mnijutes for a veggie "burger" on a whole wheat "roll" to go. The burger was actually a pile of mushy lentils and the roll was 2 slices of bread. Considering the average lunch entree costs $20 I was utterly disappointed and will not go back.

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by Shmuel A on 11/16/2006


    I don’t know where to start this is an excellent restaurant. On the many occasions that I have bin here my meals were A1. What more can I say they make a damn good cheese cake?

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by Marilyn and Ronald on 09/05/2006

    The Best Kosher Dairy in NYC

    This past Sunday, my husband and I, and two friends (who had never been to your restaurant), came by for lunch. We were on a bus trip from Baltimore. We had a wonderful lunch (our 3rd time here), and even took dinner for my husband to eat (at the non-kosher restaurant included in our trip). Everything (food and service) were excellent, as usual. Can't wait to get back. Our thanks to Scott who emailed us the Brunch menu. Thanks again!

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by MMF on 8/21/06 on 08/23/2006

    Noisy but good food

    We sat upstairs and it was quite noisy. The food was a little slow in coming but very good when it came. I had the grilled trout and it was superb. The tuna steak was also good. I thought most of the desserts were tasty, but don't order the pecan pie. Not good. The wait staff was polite and fairly attentive. Our water glasses were never empty. Always a plus on a hot day. Overall, I would grade it a B to B+.

  • My Most Favorite Food

    Posted by Under whelmed on 04/03/2006

    Not worth it

    I think I am the only Jew over 20 who was born and raised in NY who had never been to My Most Favorite...until last week, that is. I had always heard good things about the eatery, but I guess either people had very low standards, or I had very high ones because I was not thrilled- with anything. The place itself was not particularly nice for a so-called "fancy restaurant". It was all right, but nothing spectacular. The service was ok, but we had to wait a long time for the food and to find a waiter to get us bread was like pulling teeth. The food, which everyone spoke so highly of, was so unbelievably expensive that I expected it to be nothing short of extraordinary. Alas, it was not. I ordered mushroom ravioli in a pesto sauce, and did not only have to add salt to give it any semblance of flavor, was still pretty hungry after it was done. I and several others at the table wondered if this was seriously the main. And then, after all that, we ordered dessert. The one thing I assumed would be more than mediocre. Remember what they say about assuming.... it's true. I have had just as good desserts at fleishig places- and they can't use milk!!! Come one, people! If you are going to name a restaurant after your desserts, you'd better make sure they're REALLY good. If you're looking for a good place, with a nice ambiance, good service and 1/2 the price. I recommend Cafe K. Save yourself the time, money, and disappointment!

3,000+ menus from the world's most diverse neighborhood.
© 2002-2014 Slick City Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MenuPages® is a trademark of Slick City Media, Inc. Disclaimer