Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Midtown South / Chelsea >
American (Traditional) >
Posted by Stomach ache on 11/01/2007
First I was told it would be 15 min... 40 min later I had to call and check on my order. The onion rings would have been good, if they werent cold. I asked for ranch along w bleu cheese with my chicken wings and only received ranch... oh yeah, and the chicken wings were sweet instead of spicy and were probably the cause of my painful stomach ache. The pears in my salad came from a jar and were hardly cut up, the goat cheese tasted like it was prepackaged, and it arrived with spinach instead of frisee, like stated on the menu. basically, I will never order from this restaurant EVER again.
Posted by Very Bad Food on 08/05/2007
My wife and I started with a app. which should have been good, but it was tasteless, greasy, we took two bits, and sent it back, then came the main course, I had a steak sandwich which was full a fat, peppers, and a lump of cheese, I only had half, my wife had a pork dish, which was covered in so much dry spice rub, thats all you could taste.The waiter ask if everything was o.k., Of course we told her no, she said the manager removed the app from the check, who cared about that we had came to eat. And just couldn't. The bottom line is the place looks, nice, maybe just for a drink or two, but stay away from the food.
Posted by Riley on 04/07/2007
Chicken paillard and accompanying side dishes were so salty my tongue burned. My husband ordered a cheeseburger rare which arrived too rare, so he asked them to cook it a bit more. He got a whole new burger (which was nice) except it had no cheese, no lettuce or tomato and was well done as a hockey puck. Server was efficient but charmless. To her credit,she was managing an unwieldy number of tables and it was before a Garden event. Oh, I was also annoyed that we didn't get a bread basket but now I think that was probably a blessing.
Posted by RangersFan on 05/26/2006
If you are going to anything at the garden, go here to eat. If its a Rangers game or a concert it becomes a great meeting place. The food is awesome too, if you go get the pot roast.
Posted by M on 04/30/2006
I went here with 3 girlfirends, 2 of us ordered the sirloin medium and when we got it, it was black and burnt, very dry, absolutely no taste. 3 of us ordered wine which tasted like water. i don't recommend this place at all. service was good though.
Posted by garden party on 01/11/2006
Great for a pre garden event.
Posted by Victor on 01/04/2006
Mustang Harry's is a decent place to grab a drink and a few appetizers before an event at the Garden. A real meal isn't such a good idea. The service is fine, and the atmosphere is sufficiently relaxed, but the main courses leave quite a bit to be desired. Stick to the basics: 1. booze and 2. appetizers that require little culinary skill.