Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Tuffy on 06/01/2010
I knew the food wasn't good when I bit into the first piece of chicken in the chicken masala. The chicken was obviously not simmered long enough in the sauce, and you can smell the unpleasant smell of insufficiently cooked chicken. The chicken tikka masala was extremely sweet, making me think that I was eating sweet and sour chicken! Even the samosa was cold and mediocre. This was by far the worst Indian food I ever had in my life.
Posted by mark on 01/23/2010
Their shrimp malai, lamb vidaloo, chicken tandoori are abosolutely delicious! I would also recommend the soft puffed poori for the appetizer along with the roshi malai for desert. This is undoubtably one of the best places I've been to in a long time.
Posted by AML on 12/22/2009
I've dined in some of the finest and most expensive Indian restaurants in the city but none compares with Mumtaz. The cuisine is superb as is the service. It's cozy size is perfect for a tete a tete, and there's never any rushing as with the midtown fineries.
Posted by Julia on 12/09/2009
It's hard to go wrong with classic indian dishes like chicken tikki masala and pishwari naan bread, but this place totally misses the mark. The food is bland and not flavorful. Huge disappointment. I would not recommend ordering from here.
Posted by Borbay on 09/24/2009
Mumtaz always delivers, especially when you take the time to visit their restaurant - which is a charming visceral mix of a subway car and a brothel. This may sound negative, but when you get there, you will see what I am talking about - excellent, authentic NYC atmosphere. The Chana Baji is incredible, as is the Lamb Masala. Great restaurant, staff and food. Highly recommended.
Posted by Foodlover on 09/19/2009
Bland, tasteless, overcooked. Very dissappointing. I'm from India and this has got to be the poorest Indian food I've tasted in New York. Don't waste your money here.
Posted by New Yorker UES on 08/08/2009
the delivery was quick and timely! But the lamb curry was a disaster. I mean he confirmed "spicy" (me being an Indian) but the lamb vindaloo came full of sugar taste (Made for American taste perhaps!) but at the same time there was tons (I mean tons) of chilli there. I guess he heard me saying spicy and he went and added lots of chilli to the already made curry. More chilli was ok with me but sugar and chilli bad combination. Spoiled my dinner ended up ordering chinese. I will never order from here again.