
Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
| Rating | Avg. Dinner Entrée |
|---|---|
| $$$$$ | Greater than $25 |
| $$$$ | $18.01 - $25 |
| $$$ | $12.01 - $18 |
| $$ | $7.01 - $12 |
| $ | Less than $7 |
Reviews + Photos from nymag.com
| Food | ![]() |
Value | ![]() |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service | ![]() |
Atmosphere | ![]() |
Posted by I'm glad it wasn't my b'day... on 07/01/2010
Keeping it real...
OK, A friend chose to go here for her b'day celebration. Maitre'd service was fine, and we were allowed to sit even though our party was incomplete. All personality ended here. Marched upstairs, which was a bit cozier than the mall-like atmosphere of the lower level. Drinks arrived promptly (fabulous chardonnay and vodka martinis). After spending what we thought too much time describing the menu, we simply beckoned for the menu to be delivered. Order: Appetizers - 1 chilled ocean platter and 1 hot ocean platter - both sufficed with the crabcakes being a standout, as were the accompanying dips/sauces; Dinner - 1 porterhouse, one cajun rib-eye, 1 rib-eye and 1 mignon. For aged beef, they sure lacked flavor and weren't very tender. The sides were delicious (mash, green beans and button mushrooms); Dessert - Key lime pie and Carrot cake...I'm no baker, but I make better. The servers were robotic with no personality, and the atmosphere was rather sterile. I hate feeling like all intentions are directed at increasing the bill, especially when it's so apparent that a party will already indulge on their own. I gave my friend a choice of venue to celebrate her b'day, but this will not be a choice on mine.
Posted by Andrea on 02/13/2010
Disbelief!
We had received a gift certificate to Morton's so we used it in White Plains. It was one of the poorest dining experiences that we ever had. The hostess took us in and abandoned us at the maitre d's stand without a word. Eventually it became evident that we were supposed to go to the bar for a drink. 35 minutes later we were seated. The waitress was so automatonic it seemed like she was on drugs. The $10.50 salad was a honeymoon salad -- "Lettuce alone." The caesar salad was the same. The steaks were mediocre and not cooked properly. We got a special which included dessert but the waitress still came by with the dessert tray to give a monotonic pitch. Perhaps she thought we would order more than one dessert. We felt totally over fawned over and pitched to. There is not atmosphere -- it is like eating in the middle of Grand Central Station. We could not wait to get out of there. Only plusses -- the crab cake and shrimp were good and the bartender was fantastic. The bill was $126 without tip -- we left shaking our heads about why anyone would drop that kind of money on this restaurant.
Posted by mark on 12/30/2009
Great food - service
Went to Morton's after a show with friends who were going to an evening show. We sat upstairs. Much more intimate and lots more attention from the wait staff. We had online coupons for a $50 per person meal without cocktails. The food was excellent and the servie first rate. Ask for upstairs and get the coupons.
Posted by Eric on 10/05/2009
Overdone in so many ways
I had to write this, and I have never had the urge to throw my opinion around, but after this poor effort by a supposed Top Notch Steakhouse, I had to chime in. My steak was way past medium rare, no sign of the waiter for half the night, so I could have eaten an hour and a half after arriving, so I endured and bit the bullet. The ribeye was tough and dry and the potato was only $8.50 extra! (I used to buy 50 lb bags for less). Add a tasteless Ceaser salad, and my partner and I escaped for 130 bucks, with a single drink each. Tip not included..........
Posted by anonymous on 02/19/2009
Top Notch Steakhouse!
Recently had a small private function held in one of the back rooms. The service and the food were off the charts. The steaks were cooked to perfection, as always, and everything was delicious. Although this is a high end chain restaurant, I rank it up there with any steakhouse in the city. Prices for an upscale steakhouse are very similar accorss the board. I would recommend this place to anyone who asks!
Posted by cheapskate on 11/10/2008
had the special at NYC midtown
I ordered steak and seafood special on two occasion. The filet was tender but lacking in beef taste. The seafood entires were ok. Staff was friendly and fast. They packed up our dessert to go without any problem. You don't need the coupon to order. If you go with an odd number of guests, you are charged $50.00 per person. Everyone should try the special. It's any cheap way to enjoy a high scale restaurant. No need for suit and tie.
Posted by Drew on 09/25/2008
great
We went to Mortons for the steak and seafood special. Food was excellent and the service was even better. I would not normally go there because of the price, but this special makes it somewhat reasonable