Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Miss Lily's

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Caribbean, Jamaican, Smoothies/Juice Bar
  • 132 W Houston St, New York NY10012 40.727741 -74.001325
  • (At Sullivan St)
  • click map to interact
  • (917) 859-4016
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 24 reviews)

Food 3.5 Value 2.9
Service 2.9 Atmosphere 3.8

Other Restaurant Info

(917) 859-4016
Place Order:
Order From Miss Lily's for delivery & takeout
Major Credit Cards Bake Shop & Melvin's Juice Box Mon-Fri: 7:30am-10pm Sat-Sun: 8:30am-10pm
Mon-Fri: 11:30am-4:30pm+5pm-1:30am Sat: 11am-4:30pm+5pm-1:30am Sun: 11am-4:30pm+5pm-11:30pm
Breakfast, Dinner, Lunch
Accepts Credit Cards, Brunch, Delivery, Good for Groups, Late Night, Online Ordering, Online Reservations, Private Parties, Take Out, Trendy

User Reviews

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by Girl on the Bowery on 07/14/2014

    Not the real deal

    I ordered the oxtails, peas & rice and cabbage. The oxtails were tiny but good flavored and juicy (maybe I got the bottom of the pot). The peas & rice were DRY as all hell. The cabbage or whatever they gave me was freeze dried and stringy.. I know this didn't come from an actual vegetable. I've had better cabbage working as a counsel for a summer camp program. I grew up with West Indians and authentic Jamaican/Trinidadian food and this was a nice imitation but not the real deal. Just order the meats, no veggies unfortunately.

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by Ashley on 06/17/2014

    Not recommended

    Okay, so I never even bother to write a review whether it's bad or good. I came to this place on father's day, and thought I would treat him to a place that has a menu he would enjoy. When we walked in the hostess was no where to be found, she was by the bar chatting away. The seating there was really cramped and theres barely space in the place. The food here was disappointing and is not the definition of jamaican food at all I'm from jamaica born and raised and I came here with high expectations but instead left very disappointed. This place is also overpriced like other people said. I ordered salmon that came too burnt and when i asked for a new one they almost gave it to me raw! My father did not order an entree, my sister ordered the buss shrimp for $21 a few apetizers and 4 non alcholic drinks. The bill came up to $135 I won't ever return to this place.

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by charles on 06/10/2014

    Poor service, rip off prices.

    I'm Jamaican, and the dishes we were served are easily made in a frying pan in five minutes, and they should be cheap, which defines Jamaican food. This restaurant charges $12 for fifty cents worth of plantains. Folks, all you do is slice up a ripe black plantain and fry it in oil for a short while. Portions are tiny although they shake every last cent from your pocket. We felt the restaurant was cheaply decorated, and we would not come back.

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by sprung on food on 02/12/2014

    Jamaican Me Hungry: Miss Lily's

    This authentic Jamaican restaurant is putting a modern spin on some of the classics of the Caribbean right in SoHo. Jazzed up with multicolored twinkle lights, diner-esc order boards and seating, this place not only serves up tasty food, but provides an environment that just makes you happy. Not to mention, your ears will enjoy the amazing reggae tunes playing on Radio Lily.

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by JAinBK on 12/27/2013

    Good Food, Highly Overpiced

    I had heard about this restaurant for a while before I actually went there. My mom was in town and so I decided to take her there for lunch. The atmosphere was strange...it is definitely not a family restaurant and my mom did not feel entirely comfortable there. We got there a little before lunch had officially started and were told to just sit at a table and a waiter would come to us once the kitchen opened. None did, we had to wave our waiter down to let him know that we were not sitting there simply for our health. After that the service was fine. The place got very crowded. The food was excellent, but the portions were tiny and the prices were ridiculously high. Now as a Jamaican, I know what good Caribbean food should taste like...and this was it, but I barely had enough food to whet my appetite. I paid twice as much as I would at another Jamaican restaurant for half the food. What you expect to find at a Caribbean restaurant is good food, cheap prices, and generous portions. For the price they are charging, I would expect to have enough food for three meals, but instead I left still feeling hungry. I've returned once and ordered from their take-out counter, the service was much better, but I left with the same feeling of being unsatisfied and having paid way too much for the privilege. And on top of it, the rice and peas tasted like the bottom of the pot. Sadly, I won't be returning to Miss Lily's. If I want overpriced Jamaican food, I can go to Negril's, where at least I know I won't go hungry, I'll feel comfortable, and I'll receive good service.

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by Reilly Ate Here on 01/12/2013

    Downtown Cool but Overpriced

    Great atmosphere and good food but the portions were too small for the price. If I'm being really picky the Jerk Chicken could have used a bit more moisture. I'd go back.

  • Miss Lily's

    Posted by Kerry on 11/19/2012


    I visited Ms Lily's for the 2nd time and must say that I hope this will not be my last. Both times I enjoyed the jerk corn and man it was delish both times when you go you must have. My friends loved the pepper shrimp and love the other appetizers that we had. The jerk chicken needed to be more spicey but I get it that not everyone is from the islands so they have to taper down the heat. The only thing this place is lacking is a dancefloor so we could work off the food that we ate. The drinks were on point (a bit pricey but good) and the food was as if my mom had cooked it. Chef was very sweet as well. Had fun will be back.

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.