Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by The Killingworths on 11/08/2006
This is truly one of the nicest pizza places on the UES. Great pizza, nice, considerate staff and prompt service. We travel out of our way to get our pizza here, it is always delicious and fresh. The pepperoni pizza is awesome and it's a great value.
Posted by Just down the street on 08/04/2006
People talk about this like it's real pizza. No sir, it isn't. Thick crust, mediocre. sauce, and average cheese. I do not recommend this pizza for delivery. It is average everytime.
Posted by Miss Alisa on 04/14/2006
It's been awhile since I've lived in New York (I now live in Chicago), but I am telling you, I think about Mimi's pizza all the time! It doesn't help matters that I prefer NY style pizza over Chicago style anyday! Chicago style pizza is bland and never cooked all the way through. You can't get good pizza here, you certainly can't get anything close to Mimi's! So eat up NYC! And next time you get to enjoy some Mimi's pizza, think of poor little me here in the Windy City.
Posted by Anonymous on 04/06/2006
Without a doubt, the best pizza I've ever had. We live outside the delivery area and there are countless pizzerias in between, but it's worth going to pick it up. We've tried all the others...no comparison.
Posted by one who knows good food on 03/27/2006
My husband and I began eating at Mimi's (on the sit-down restaurant side) about 4 years ago...and we have been hooked ever since. Although we've heard (and seen) that they have great pasta and delicious specials, we've never ordered anything but pizza. Our favorites are: a whole, plain pie (just tasty tomato sauce, lots of cheese, and that golden crust) and our newest discovery, the Classic Margherita Pie made with tomato sauce, FRESH mozzarella , and basil (like at Grimaldi's and Lombardi's). Lately, we have been eating that Margherita pie at Mimi's once a week because it is THAT good. We don't even want to order it delivery--somehow it just tastes best right there in the restaurant. Sure, we are fans of Grimaldi's, Lombardi's, Nick's, Patsy's of East Harlem (and all the other coal or brick oven joints), but I have to say that Mimi's sauce and crust are the best--despite the fact that they are using a (gasp!) conventional oven. Mimi's is said to have been a favorite of Paul and Linda Mc Cartney back in the day--and it is rumored that he had a pizza sent to him in England via airplane when he just had to have it. Yep, it really is that good.
Posted by Anonymous on 02/07/2006
Pizza is fantastic, we miss that place, we live very far now and we dream to comeback...un bacio a Mimi' pizzeria from Italy
Posted by disappointed on 01/29/2006
Having lived in the neighborhood for more than 20 years, Mimi's was always my favorite and only place to grab a slice or order a pizza to my home. Unfortunately, it has gone down hill over the years since the parents died, and and has since been very inconsistent. Recently, one pizza was burned, the other had almost no sauce and it is in general a gamble to order from there.