Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Make My Cake

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • Desserts, Bakeries
  • 121 St Nicholas Ave, New York NY10026 40.803731 -73.953084
  • (At 116th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 932-0833
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 5 reviews)

Food 4.7 Value 4.5
Service 3.9 Atmosphere 4.7

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 932-0833
(212) 932-3198
Mon-Thu: 7:30am-8pm Fri: 7:30am-9pm Sat: 9am-9pm Sun: 9am-7pm
Kid Friendly

User Reviews

  • Make My Cake

    Posted by EJ on 07/10/2012

    Cobbler heaven

    I go to different bakeries for different things. I have a spot for red velvet a spot for strawberry tarts a place for lemon cake this is my cobbler spot. The peach and the apple are some of the best I've ever had and the best thing is can't make up your mind on which cobbler you want get the half and half the best of both worlds

  • Make My Cake

    Posted by annoyed on 11/17/2010

    Very displeased!

    I called the store a few days before I place my order which would have been 2 anniversary cakes and cup cakes for a sweet sixteen. I called just to get an idea of pricing decorating etc. The young lady I spoke to was very pleasant and helpful. When I called the next day ...oh boy the owner was very short tempered and I was told all the info I was given was incorrect. I did not just start coming to your store. Please remember your business has come from word of mouth.... your reputation is all you have no matter how great your cakes are. The same people that have brought you this far you should want to keep them. Very displeased!!

  • Make My Cake

    Posted by Morningside Diner on 07/27/2010

    A Wonderful Harlem Establishment

    I was a bit skeptical before ordering a graduation cake from here because of a few poor reviews on other sites. However, I'm glad I ignored that advice because the red velvet/cream cheese frosting cake I ordered was absolutely delicious. The 8" round cake was plenty to serve 10 people because it was so dense and moist (the way cake should be!). The prices aren't fantastic for the area but are comparable to any other high quality bakery in the city. The service was fine, nothing spectacular but adequate. This will definitely be my go-to bakery for special occasion cakes in the future.

  • Make My Cake

    Posted by ValuFoodie on 06/09/2010


    I can't speak for all the items on the menu, but one thing is for sure-- here you are bound to find one of the tastiest cupcakes you've ever had in your life. The place is adorable, the service is friendly, and the cupcakes are to die for. Make My Cake is definitely tops in my book, if you haven't tried it yet Make a point of doing so.

  • Make My Cake

    Posted by Celia on 10/09/2009

    Let them eat cake!!!!!

    This place is great. I used to go when they were on 110th, and try to go often to the new location. It is truly home made. The cake is delicious and now the place is as cute as the cake is good. Go there now!!!!!!

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.