Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by sprung on food on 02/20/2014
Since 1985, they bake everything right there in the shop from scratch, using the finest and freshest ingredients. Which also leads to an amazing, wafting pie smell on the street outside. Not a bad way to lure people in. They also have some other baked goods, but really specializing in their pies. They have full sized, mini-sized and by the slice (insider tip: if you're just wanting a slice, and you're particular about the flavor, you might want to call before visiting since they only cut up three different pies per day at random).
Posted by EJ on 09/18/2011
Have always loved their pies since they first opened. I had not had a pie from them for over a year so I headed to the shop to pie shop I got my key lime, blueberry and apple then I saw the bread pudding w lemon sauce. No matter what you go there for get the bread pudding it will put a smile on your face and a song in your tummy
Posted by shabuchwae on 09/02/2010
I adore this place! Why, you may wonder??!! It's uber clean. The staff are always SOOO pleasant and accommodating that one cashier even went above and beyond by letting me use a coupon in combination with a special they were running that day! That's the way I like the businesses I support to roll: screw the fine print - give everyone, especially the regulars, exceptional service! They even inspired me to try to replicate their Apple Sour Cream Pie (which I did, if I do say so myself :-). I'm a super picky (alright...just say bourgeois! I can take it :-) foody and I've enjoyed everything I've ever eaten here with NO complaint! My top fav pies (as of now) are the mississipi mud (palpably dense!!!), three berry (phenom!!) and the sour cream apple (OM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM!!!). I can't recommend this place enough, especially for a laid back afternoon date with a loved one. Quality food. Quality service. All around awesomeness! A bit on the pricey side...but you're seriously getting quality (can I say that word enough??!! :-). The experience, whether dining in or out, is well worth the expenditure. You've got to treat yourself at least once in your life to this true NYC find :-)
Posted by EJ on 02/25/2010
i have been going here since they fist opened when they were still having concerts on the pier. would always buy the small pies for me and my friends.always made sure to stop by during 9th ave food festival.these are the type of pies that when you ask someone if they know of this place you both start jumping up and down because that is just how good the pies are
Posted by Anonymous on 08/25/2008
The pies and cakes are amazing! Top off any choice with ice cream and you have yourself a little slice of heaven on earth. Forget Magnolia, this place has better desserts, you can actually sit down to eat after ordering and I've never encountered an abnormally long line.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/06/2008
I dont know about the previous review poster, but the pies here are wonderful. The sour cream apple walnut is my personal favorite. It's best heated up and the sour cream gives it an unusually yummy flavor. Supermarket apple pies dont measure up to the pies here.
Posted by Anonymous on 06/04/2008
Not impressed at all with the pies. I tried the mississippi mud pie and the sour cream apple walnut pie. The apple walnut was a little better than the mud pie, which basically tasted like a brownie with extra sugar. You can get a pie just as good, if not better at your local supermarket . This place is definitely not recommended.