MenuPages

Been to the city a handful of times and this is by far the best little place I've found. The cookies are heavy but soft at the same time. The people are real and down to earth. They just like to make good cookies I guess. I had two of the chocolate chip walnut at his request. Perfect ratios of chocolate and walnut to cookie. Grab a few and go to Central Park. For those ten minutes, you will own the city. Oh, and don't forget to grab milk!

As I saw the cookies sitting in the glass case I thought, Oh, these don' look that special! I bought a few and headed into Central Park. I ate them about an hour after I bought them. The inside still soft and moist. The chocolate just BURST-ED into my mouth. It wasn't as sweet as some of the other reviews say, maybe I'm just used to overly sweet desserts. I'm not a fan of walnuts, but there aren't a gazillon of them, I didn't even notice I was eating walnuts until I tasted one. Heads up, if you're expecting LOTS of walnuts you may be disappointed. What I would like to add, is that the cashier was very inattentive and rude. She repeated my order wrong, which I corrected, but then proceeded to still put in my bag the wrong order. Running late for an event I didn't check my order and was about to get ALL upset once I noticed the mistake, until I realized the dark chocolate choco chip cookie is rather delicious! :)

This place has the best chocolate chip cookie in NYC or in the whole world for that fact. Delicious fresh and the staff is super friendly!

I like their cookies a lot but I wished they would consider making one with nuts (think macadamias, pecans, cashews) and without chocolate nor raisins.

This place is crazy good. Never had a bad thing here. Only thing I'll say is it's super expensive for what you get. It's good and I'll go back, but it's very pricey.

these are some tasty cookies. At $4 a pop (with only 4 types of cookie available) they better be. the line might be out the door but they move fast but once you get that first savory bite in your mouth its all worth it. I live on the east side and I make the trek to the UWS once in a while so i can get one of these tasty treats. the cookies are HUGE so its easy to share. and if you dont eat your cookie right away and it gets cold, its still yummy after nuking it in the microwave. definitely have to try at least once. it might seem like a simple cookie, but there so many bad cookies (aka the cement cookie) out there thats it nice to know someone can do it right!

cookies are always fresh and warm, and gooey the best experience is if you eat them right there. Once they are cold and ungooey, they are just OK. But at almost $4.00 a pop they are not cheap either.