Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

  • RatingAvg. Dinner Entrée
    $$$$$Greater than $25
    $$$$$18.01 - $25
    $$$$12.01 - $18
    $$$7.01 - $12
    $Less than $7
  • British (Traditional), Teahouses
  • 56 Irving Pl, New York NY10003 40.735954 -73.986954
  • (At E 18th St)
  • click map to interact
  • (212) 533-4466
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 11 reviews)

Food 4.2 Value 3.3
Service 4.0 Atmosphere 4.5

Other Restaurant Info

(212) 533-4466
(800) 685-1447
(212) 533-4611
Major Credit Cards Seatings Mon-Fri: 3pm and 5pm Sat-Sun: 12pm, 2:30pm and 5pm
Accepts Credit Cards, Online Reservations, Private Parties, Prix Fix Menus, Romantic

User Reviews

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by GISELE on 05/16/2015

    Better off elsewhere

    My friend and I have been coming to Lady Mendl's Tea Salon for many years, to celebrate our birthdays. Yesterday we were four. I noticed that the little charming fancy sugar cubes were missing. They could have done without the soup, and we were served four sandwich each - before they came around again with more. The cake was so paper thin, before you had a much bigger piece, and again, we were served four cookies on the plate, with no strawberries. And last, but not least, the tea was very watered down. Our server was charging us $10.00 more a person, before we pointed out her error. I know, next year we will find another tea house. They have new management, however, they should go back to basics.

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by Venus D'Royce on 01/20/2015

    Not a serious tea parlour

    The atmosphere is charming and the room is cozy. We were seated however near a radiator and a back window, nothing to look at but waiters going back and forth. You would suppose at least that would mean we got waited on quickly. When finally served, the tea selection is just four kinds: Earl Gray, English Breakfast a tisane and decaf. A four year old would make better tea for her dolls. 2 x 2 in. sandwiches were tasty but no one offered more.The 16 layer cake was both sugary and tasteless. When I asked for more tea they tried to top off my cup, when I complained they refilled it with fresh hot tea but it was not the kind I had chosen. The place has raised its pries by a third in the past three years and decreased the quality. When I go for tea I want good tea and a memorable experience. Here I was left to feel the hotel is just interested in making maximum money not in being a true cultural institution. In other words it is phony, all hype. It's pretty though so if you do not mind risking getting a bad table you can pretend this is a real tea service and maybe enjoy it a bit. But if you know tea at all you will be very disappointed.

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by SMcD on 12/26/2014

    Charming atmosphere, but you're better off elsewhere

    The setting of this salon is cozy and enchanting and sets great expectations. However the tea is an incredible disappointment. First of all, they don't know how to make the actual tea. Both our table and the table behind ours had to return the pots because they were too watery. The courses are chintzy, even by British tea standards, and were ok, but not exceptional given the price.

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by Charlene on 01/09/2014

    Ok, great server but rude rude concierge

    I have just returned from there now, the service from the server was great he was polite and attentive, the scones were amazing but the sandwiches just tiny. On leaving the concierge who went to get our coats was so rude, he made me walk to him with the ticket ( which I usually wouldn't mind only when I walked over but it wasn't close enough for his liking and he would not put his hand out to take the ticket I had to stretch over to him as he was too lazy to do his job). On returning with our jackets stood in the hallway and made me go and collect them from him he just held them out like they were infected and was getting agitated when I was waited from him to bring them over to us as anyone going to get a jacket for the customer would usually. I have been to some of the top afternoon tea places in London such as the Ritz and Claridges and have never been treated so badly by a snobby member of staff thinking he was so far above his station. They need to be careful with this staff member as he will soon dwindle their good reviews by bad ones if he keeps dolling out bad service. unfortunately this tainted our experience and leave me giving only an 'Ok' review.

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by Lady Jane on 01/18/2011

    Big disappointment

    I'd heard so much about this place. After having been there (granted..just once) I really think it's nothing special. Disappointing nibbles and over-priced.

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by Amelia Eve on 05/26/2010

    Intimate Jazz Age Elegance

    From the moment you open the heavy oak front door, you are enveloped in a heady, old-fashioned environment with a mix of antiques, fresh flowers, jazz music, and candlelight. The service is prompt but not pushy, and the food just keeps coming. The sandwiches were freshly made, and the egg salad with parsley was a perfect mix of tradition and innovation. The scones are rich and buttery with a tender crust and abundant clotted cream and rich raspberry jam. There was a good selection of teas, but they were bagged, not loose, and mine was stewed and bitter by the end of the meal. Great atmosphere for a special occasion when you want to experience a peaceful indulgence.

  • Lady Mendl's Tea Salon

    Posted by foodiesRus on 10/22/2008


    An avid fan of high tea, I must say that this hidden treasure of a tea salon is simple, classy, and exquisite. The place is beyond gorgeous and enjoyed the vintage setting. The salad was light and refreshing. The dainty miniature tea sandwiches were delectable. My fave was the smoked salmon and the turkey cranberry had a sweet savory twist to it. The green tea was earthy, yet light and a perfect complement to the sweet treats - scones, petit fours, cookies, and choco strawberries. Come here and leave with a smile =.)

© 2015 GrubHub, Inc. All rights reserved.