Welcome to MenuPages - Please Select a city:

La Piazza di Eataly

  • $
  • Alcohol, Italian, Tapas
  • 200 5th Ave, New York 10010 40.741967 -73.989491
  • (At 23rd St)
  • click map to interact
  • (646) 398-5100
  • 0

User Ratings (Based on 9 reviews)

avg-come back to15
Food 3 Value 2_5
Service 3 Atmosphere 2_5

Other Restaurant Info

(646) 398-5100
Take Out Major Credit Cards
Mon-Sat: 11am-10pm Sun: 11am-9:30pm
Accepts Credit Cards, Lunch, Take Out, Wheelchair Accessible

User Reviews

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by Rick on 2014-08-07

    I could have gotten lost...

    ...in a good way. Don't go there on an empty stomach because you'll leave broke. They have everything that a guinnie like me loves. Its very crowded and thats the only draw back. It's a bit expensive but its NYC expensive so it was expected. Just a great

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by ted on 2012-01-03

    I dont get it

    So many people say this is bad pizza. This is real italian naples pizza! The real deal, not brooklyn, not yr favorite place in the bronx, not New Jersey. Real Neopolitian pizza the way they make it there, Italy, Naples. Its awesome, chewy, gooey crust, fr

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by MikeYNYC on 2011-07-25

    Nice when it's not too busy

    Went on July 4th weekend as to avoid the crowds (everyone is out of town.) Had a very nice time eating and drinking at the high tops in the piazza.

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by Marzi on 2011-06-15

    Not authentic enough

    The fish which we tried twice was simply grilled brushed with olive oil. One time it was fine and the next it was nothing special. Prices are high and the vegetables in the fish area are also nothing special and were overcooked. There are much better a

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by Dag on 2011-02-04

    Pizza was great

    I disagree with the pizza naysayers, I think the pizza is delicious! and have ordered the same pie at least four times!

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by Joanne on 2010-11-16

    Better pizza elsewhere

    You can get GREAT pizza in NY...this is not great pizza

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by Leya on 2010-11-01

    Good Pasta subpar pizza

    The pasta was very good, cooked well and decently priced. The pizza however was not good at all, and was not worth the 18$ as it could only feed one person max. It was soggy and not crispy at all. Stick to one of his other restaurants or the supermarket i

  • La Piazza di Eataly

    Posted by Johann on 2010-11-01

    Not recommended

    This take out pizza was not good. It's crust was doughy and totally undercooked. Very very bland taste (had the 3 cheese pizza). The cheese slides of the pizza when I tried to take a piece out of the box. The crust was so bad and undercooked that when I l

© 2018 Grubhub, Inc. All rights reserved.