Hold down Control (PC) or Command (Mac) key + mouseclick to select more than one option
Posted by Anonymous on 04/04/2005
Despite what the other reviewer wrote, Katz's is NOT a kosher deli. However, it is quite good. Like everyone else said, go for the pastrami or corned beef sandwiches. Be prepared to have leftovers.
Posted by Ging34789 on 02/18/2005
I have been eating in NYC for years and tried to avoid this place because of all the hype. I finally caved and got the pastrami and it is unbelievable. Sure it is expensive, but it is well worth it. The hot dogs were nothing to write home about, and it has it's quirks but if you want pastrami, this is the place to go.
Posted by Anonymous on 01/05/2005
YUM! YUM! Succulent pastrami, and I usually NEVER would order it anywhere else. But one taste and I was HOOKED! Chicken noodle soup is awesome too....thick, hearty noodles and chunks of chicken. The turkey sandwich is a little dry for my liking though. As for the atmosphere, it's not really a "date" place...very vintage, kinda dirty at times (there can be flies). And don't you DARE lose your ticket.
Posted by djny10003 on 12/30/2004
I always thought that kosher kitchens were always kept very clean, but eating at Katz's I learned that's not always true. The counters needed wiping, and it was just kind of gross. Nobody but tourists eat here. The ordering system, where you take a ticket and wait in line is a big pain in the a**.
Posted by NYer on 12/28/2004
I have to strongly disagree with the posting "Second Best." I have been to both Katz's and Carnegie Deli numerous times, having lived in NYC for many years, and Katz's is hands-down better. Don't get me wrong, Carnegie Deli is no slouch either, but this is no contest. In addition, the atmosphere is so much better at Katz's, with the walk-up ordering and long counter of sandwich makers. In addition, Carnegie Deli caters primarily to tourists while you'll see many more locals at Katz's... always a good sign of good eateries.
Posted by Robert on 12/22/2004
At least I hope that's where you go. Ok, I can't vouch for too much on the menu, and I think the prices are a bit hefty for a sandwich, BUT....the pastrami is simply the most delicious I've ever tasted...period. At almost $13, it's a bit sinful for a sandwich, but the meat is of such unsurpassed quality, I actually prefer eating my sandwich with a knife and fork...it makes me feel like I'm having a complete meal. And believe me, the pastrami sandwich will leave you as satisfied as any other sinful indulgence. Oh yeah, the pickles are great too, and with a Dr. Brown's cream soda, you're in for a real NY Jewish treat that is fit for a king.
Posted by chuck6289 on 12/12/2004
After visiting for the first time, we liked it, but have to agree with the previously listed reviewer. The Carnegie is better. The food was very good, but prices were higher and portions smaller than the Carnegie. If I am on this side of town, I would eat here again, but to choose, my choice is as previously stated. The chicken noodle soup was very good on a cold day.